Censored on CiF, community standards, Guardian Watch, latest
Comments 12

What “community standards” did this comment breach?#11

This comment was censored by the Guardian. Which of the well-publicised CiF “community standards” did it breach?

snapshot of where it was:

Screen Shot 2015-07-07 at 14.17.06

Which of the Guardian’s “community standards” did it breach?

  • Does it “misrepresent the Guardian and its journalists”?
  • Is it “persistent trolling or mindless abuse”?
  • Is it “spam-like”? Or “obviously commercial”?
  • Is it “racism, sexism, homophobia or hate-speech”?
  • Is it “extremely offensive of threatening?”?
  • Is it “flame-wars based on ingrained partisanship or generalisations”?
  • Is it not “relevant”?

If none of the above – why was it taken down?

see our archive of censored comments. And if you see any egregious examples of the Guardian censoring its “free” comment sections – email us at editor@off-guardian.org, and send us screen caps if possible

12 Comments

  1. iusedtopost@the guardian says

    I have had around 6 previous (and moderated) usernames with the Guardian over the last 3 years.

    Each time I get moderated for I know not what. My opinions, for what they are worth, cover the spectrum but essentially defend Russia when in comparison to the murder and mayhem created by the West in the name of democracy ad freedom.

    While my retorts can be competitive they are never in breach of any laws but they get removed at will and eventually I am moderated…usually after I publicise what the moderators are doing.

    iusedtopost is my most recent moderated ID……nothing overly controversial in there out with the usual 4 letter expletives occasionally!

    Essentially if you criticise any of the following you are on your way out;

    Their anti all things Russia stance
    Their all things pro America stance
    Their all things pro EU stance
    Their lets hug and love an illegal migrant stance
    Israel anything/jewish anything/New Khazaria anything
    Mentioning Freemasons and other occultists

    Ad nauseum…..

    Personally I am finished with it all. The day will come quite soon if they are all not extremely careful when the mushroom clouds appear all over Europe and the UK and people like Sean “of the dead” Walker are heard to be muttering……

    “It wasn’t meant to be this way”

    Liked by 1 person

  2. variation32 says

    Hi all.

    I am seething because I have been placed on pre-moderation.

    My crime was reminding the Guaridan that in an article by Gary Younge published on 12th Nov, (by sheer coincidence one day before the airs attacks) he defined French secularism as uniquely targetted against Muslims, forcing them to eat pork and drink wine.

    The sort of atrocious kind of sentiment that should never be published, in my opinion, in the guise of analytical observation. Since then, I have also commented on how many articles since the Paris attacks, and which can be read as aoplogists for religious extremism, are closed for comments within an hour or so of opening. I find the pretence to be staging debate (“Facts are sacred, comment is free” they crow), coupled witht he fact that they are smothering it, morally reprehensible.

    The pre-mod warning gives a link to the reasons why. I use my comments now to challenge the moderator to explain exactly which one of these conditions (trolling, personal abuse and so on). Answer? Pah.

    Like

  3. denk says

    that was fast, deleted less than 10 min. after posting in the guardian…
    http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/jul/18/british-tourists-northern-china-deported-inner-mongolia#comment-55963420

    there’r lots of points raised by posters in this minor thread, plenty misconeptions,
    hope this helps !

    on this case,
    cia/mi6 shenanigans in china well documented, they are up to their eyeballs from the tam destabilisation to tibet, xinjiang, hk, civil and labor unrests.
    its highly plausible that these *charity
    group has been caught, or perceived to engage in monkey bussiness like fanning mongol independence movement or inciting jihad against the han infidels.

    cia/mi6 have been using jihadists mercs since the day of afghan war, later in kosovo, macedonia, libya, syria, chechyna, xinjiang…..

    on animal abuses,
    *the current record holders are ukus,
    exhibit a – gasing hundreds of cats , dogs belonged to the chagosians to force them to vacate the isle for an murkkan base.

    exhibit b – imported 5000 animals to the bikini island for radiation test after setting off dozens of nuke bombs.
    these just for starters,

    on human rights abuses,
    *the current record holders are ukus,
    re, diego garcia, bikini island, okinawa, jeju, christma island etc ….these are just kids stuffs tho when compared to the crimes in indonesia, nam , laos, cambodia, iraq, yugo, afpak, …

    on un-peace loving countries,
    the current record holders are ukus,
    do i need to trot out the evidences ?

    Like

  4. I have recently been “pre-moderated” by the Guardian PC Bolsheviks. Why don’t they simply call it, censorship. This is how they spin it:

    “If your account has been placed in pre-moderation, any comments you post won’t appear on the site immediately, but will be reviewed by a moderator first. When you post a comment, a message will indicate that your comment is awaiting moderation.”

    Since my comments contained no offensive language and no abuse whatsoever, the reason for censorship, apparently, was because some zealot at Cif disliked a contradictory opinion. Of course, nobody desiring open debate could possibly consent to having their comments filtered and pre-censored, so I’m dropping the account; good riddance, too.

    The hilarious part is the Guardian label, Comment is Free.

    Like

  5. Guest says

    Love the name Spellingcat!
    Well done for trying to challenge the guardian censorship of comments that don’t fit their neo-con agenda.
    The comments page just reads like GCHQ and NSA have taken over. The rigid uncritical acceptance of all things american as right is very scripted. George Bush never got such unconditional support

    Like

    • spellingcat says

      Thank you.. I wanted something close to ‘belling cat’, but ‘spelling cat’ with a subliminal ‘rat’, was the best i could come up with..
      (particularly since i am now up to 5 new emails/profiles, ive had to re-create in 18 months). Its funny, ive never been banned or moderated for abuse.. Its when i take time to carefully deconstruct an authors article, showing it for what it is, is when i get into trouble.

      Like

  6. spellingcat says

    Haha… I logged on here, hoping to vent…
    I didnt expect offguardian to beat me to it!
    Thank you for bringing my comment (and now my BLOCKED guardian account…not the first time) to attention.
    Any advice?

    Like

    • Hi there. Glad you found us. Best advice is – keep going back for more because that’s exactly what they are hoping you won’t do.

      …and make caps of all your comments. 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

    • They censored my comments to Shaun Walker’s latest lying screed. Walker wrote an article in which he questioned the motives of a former opponent of Putin who now has come out in support of the rebels in Eastern Ukraine. Mr. Walker just couldn’t comprehend it, since we all know what a terrible bastard Putin is. So I make a two line comment about Walker’s previous bullshit story about how he followed and accompanied a Russian Column across the Ukrainian Border and now I’m banned for life. Does Shaun Walker’s mama own the Guardian?

      Like

      • spellingcat says

        That same day, Shaun was writing his story about Cheese. At the height of Russia’s rouble crisis late last year, in one day S.W had either authored or coauthored 4 articles to do with Russia. but all from different locations spread across the Federation. Shaun must be some kind of ‘Super Spook’.

        Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s