Guardian Watch, Kit, latest
Comments 6

“Russian data law provokes fear in persons unknown” – Shaun Walker

by Kit


It seems many people have forgotten who Edward Snowden is. To refresh your memories, he is an ex-NSA intelligence analyst currently hiding out somewhere in Moscow. Two years ago he leaked information and documents proving that the NSA and GCHQ have been spying on pretty much everyone that uses the internet – this was a big deal in the Guardian, you may recall.

You probably didn’t need me to tell you that – but apparently Shaun Walker was sick that day – or maybe all that info was on the hard drives the Guardian editor took an angle-grinder to – because in his most recent tripe on Russian politics he portrays new legislation, to store Russian electronic data on Russian soil, as an autocratic clampdown to “tighten control of the internet”. Yes, seriously.

The headline is deliciously irony-free:

Russian data law fuels web surveillance fears!!

OK, I added the exclamation points – but they were heavily implied in the text. He doesn’t say, in the brief and odd article, exactly what fears are being fuelled, and to whom they belong. But there are “fears”. So…you know, look out.

Now, it seems to me a more honest rendering of the situation would be:

Russian data law fueled by web surveillance fears

But then, I don’t get paid to portray myself as some kind of anti-authoritarian super hero. Battling international tyrants with nothing but a twitter account and my limited wits. Would that we could all make a living that way.

The wonderful thing, though, is that in his tired and biased piece, Walker stumbles backwards into telling the almost-truth:

Rules requiring firms to store data of Russian citizens on Russian soil seen as a way for Putin to tighten control over internet

In yet another delightfully vague assertion, Walker neglects to mention just who this “internet control” is being taken from. In this case that would be Google, Facebook and the Western intelligence services.

This will be one of those things that Western people rail against, that cod-psychologists analyse to death in op-ed pieces for the Wall Street Journal or the New York Times. It doesn’t require any of that. This law, simply put, is to protect Russian people and Russia’s national interests – and yet the MSM will complain. Mainly because it will be an inconvenience to Western corporate interests and the alphabet agencies. But also because it throws into sharp relief the limp, impotent, borderline treasonous responses of Angela Merkel, Francouis Hollande et al to the revelation that – in the moderin world – the privacy of their citizens means absolutely nothing.


  1. MSM Sock Puppets says

    “Would you prefer your private and business data be kept in your country or in China?”

    Shucks, I don’t know. If I keep it over there, maybe I’ll earn some points that I can eventually redeem for a new made-in-PRC De Walt hammer drill.


  2. Pingback: Russia's Data Law Takes Control Away From Google, Facebook and the CIA – CJCL | Timber Exec

  3. Guest says

    Spot on!!! Excellent response to the Walker rubbish in the guardian.
    You are so right- It is clear he must have been off-sick during the whole of snowdens revelations!!!

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Congratulations on a well-written article! I was working on a take-down of this latest garbage from Shawn Walker and had even used the same word, “tripe” (now revised to “garbage” as above), to describe it.

    Also, your article clearly identified the most salient nonsense in this latest Walker Screed, so you have also saved me some time. The good news is that I have some things to add to your piece and will append them as a comment later today.

    Liked by 2 people

  5. This is the law that every country should have! Why the f*ck should your personal and business data be stored in USA where they are completely available to NSA, CIA and all US government instead in your home country??? Even if Snowden didn’t reveal that NSA collects everything from US servers and conducts not just political and personal espionage but also economic one, it just makes sense to keep your data inside your country unless you wanna specifically move it. Same goes for USA citizen, and since I know some of you are very self centric and China is a boogey man to many Americans lets reverse situation. Instead of USA servers lets use China servers. Would you prefer your private and business data be kept in your country or in China?

    Liked by 1 person


Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s