VIDEO: "Rethinking Putin: A talk by Prof. Steven F Cohen"

Prof. Stephen Cohen offers a rare, thoughtful and objective consideration of Vladimir Putin – not as a demon or a messiah – but as human being. Delivered on the annual Nation cruise, December 2, 2017, introduced by Nation Editor and Publisher Katrina vanden Heuvel.


newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Marcus
Reader
Marcus

I was just reading Saker’s analysis of the Russian election. I generally admire the guy but i don’t agree with him much here. My principle issue with his is his diagnosis of Putin as a neoliberal, which seems extraordinarily botchy analysis for someone as astute as the Saker. I’ll re-post rhe comment I made over there (which is currently in moderation): http://thesaker.is/russian-presidential-elections-boring-useless-and-necessary/ Putin a neo-liberal? Putin has increased the role of the state in the economy, increased welfare and state-spending and decreased debt – this is almost the exact opposite trajectory a neoliberal (in te current sense of the word)… Read more »

Mary Smith
Reader
Mary Smith

I just read it. My feeling is Saker should stick to military breakdowns, which he’s brilliant at. Politically he seems a bit clueless and wildly self-contradictory. In the past he’s said Putin needs to balance the extremes of his government as you point out, but now he’s diagnosing Putin’s personal beliefs based on actions! I also agree that the Russian economics of the last 18 years have been anything but neoliberal. They have been consciously rolling back on neoliberalism as much as possible given the framework. My own gut feeling about Putin is he could be a social democrat/soft-left socialist.… Read more »

vexarb
Reader

 This quote from President Putin after his meeting with Prime Minister Natanyahoo: Putin said that memory of the Holocaust is “a warning against any attempt to jump on the idea of global domination, to announce, build or assert one’s grandeur based on racism, ethnic or any other supremacy. Russia categorically rejects any such attempt.” Anoher excerpt from his speech: “Zero tolerance for anti-Semitism, or any manifestations of xenophobia and ethnic strife bring Russia and Israel closer. We closely cooperate, including in countering attempts to falsify history, to revise the outcomes of World War II, to deny the Holocaust, or… Read more »

candideschmyles
Reader

This excerpt unfortunately ends where for me it gets interesting. Putin has indeed a very positive attitude toward the Jewish diaspora in Russia but I remain very much in the dark as to his attitude toward the ultra-Zionism that pervades not just Likudite Israel but the deep state of western hegemonic empire. Indeed it is the Zionists in the US and Europe who beat the anti-Russian war drums so feverishly and who clearly set the agenda on the personal vilification of Putin himself. Yesterday Netanyahu, perhaps the most vile and bloodthirsty individual alive on the planet today, met with Putin… Read more »

rtj1211
Reader
rtj1211

That should be broadcast on Prime Time US TV, coast to coast, to teach Americans how to speak respectfully without becoming sycophantic or credulously hero-worshipping……a skill that should be deeply engrained in any nation purporting to be worthy of global leadership……..

vexarb
Reader

Nice to find the old Yankee spirit of Mr.Deeds still alive and, in its gentle folksy way, still kicking. Agree 100% with every word. The amazing thing: This is news? This is “controversial”? A sign of how far the MSM have sunk. The vilification of Russian President by the MSM almost unprecedented; and is equalled only by its absolutely unprecedented vilification of US President Trump. What’s their game?
“The bird hath fouled its nest” — As You Like It

Barbara Mullin
Reader

So sad that so many of “The Nation” writers fall into line repeating the corporate MSM fake news about Russiagate. The real Russiagate obviously was the US coup done by Victoria Nuland, Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama and Joe Biden. Oliver Stone’s latest movie “Ukraine On Fire” tells the story but you won’t see it in the corporate news.

Arrby
Reader

When I discovered the alternative media many years ago, The Nation was one of the first alt websites I visited frequently. As well, I would buy the mag often. And The Nation was also one of the first orgs that I realized was not a people’s organization, but was mainly interested in getting their Democratic monster, whoever, in the White House. To say that Stephen is connected to The Nation is an understatement. He’s married to Katrina vanden Heuvel, editor of The Nation. For this reason, and for the reason that Stephen’s a member of the evil Council on Foreign… Read more »

Kolokol
Reader
Kolokol

Stephen has sent a letter of resignation to the
CFR.

Arrby
Reader

I should think so. Why did he ever join?