It’s Progress, Dummy
Todd Hayen
According to the sheep world, nothing that is happening is bad. Technology is running wild, robots and AI are taking over the world, Digital IDs, CBDCs, cell phones gone wile, on and on and on. None of it is bad. It’s just progress, and to oppose any of it is opposing progress, and opposing the advancement of humankind.
Humans are advancing emotionally as well, we no longer insist there are only two sexes, everyone has the right to be anything they wish to be. In fact, it is all so beautiful it is magical. If I was born with a penis, and every cell in my body is screaming out that I am a male, isn’t it a beautiful thing that I can decide I am actually a woman?
And isn’t it beautiful that I can give “birth” to a baby, and have it feed on my male breasts, sucking out nutrients in a futile effort to stay alive? (Didn’t someone try to do this once with a snake?—and it didn’t work.)
This is progress—we have become so loving, and so accommodating, and so liberal, that anyone can express any sort of identification they choose, male, female, horse, dog, bat, weasel. What a wonderful human expression that is! So free! So creative! So liberating! So much an exercise of our fundamental right as a human being!
And not only can we believe that about ourselves, but we can insist on laws that force everyone around us to believe it too. In fact, doctors can even perform the necessary surgical procedures to make us look and feel like what we are identifying with. (They can’t make us be whatever we want, just look and feel it, only God can make us be something other than what we were born with.)
Not only can we identify as a different sex, or even a different species, than what we were born as, we can be anything we want to be even if we don’t deserve it or have the physical and mental capacity to be it!
We are all winners, “be all that you can be” no matter what! We have the physique to fight fires and carry people out of burning buildings even if we are weak and physically incapable. We have the option to be a brain surgeon without any formal training, we have the right to fly helicopters, control planes, fight wars, play competitive sports. Anything.
If we want to do it, we have the right and should be allowed to do it. We have the right to live anywhere we want in the world, to transcend laws, and be and do whatever we choose. (We can try, but most likely we won’t be successful at it, yet everyone around us has to pretend we are stellar in our efforts!!) And most importantly, nobody can stop us.
This is progress, dummy, what else is it?
In reality this is the effects of grandiose narcissism. Humans now believe they are God, and can, as God, create reality. For example, God has limited our expression as a biological entity to either male or female. But since we are now God we can change that and just “say” we are not the sex we are born with (as God intended) and we have the technical know-how to adjust the material elements to express, materially and biologically, the sex we have decided to be.
Only we don’t. We can alter the gross elements of gender (well, only a few things like breasts and penises, and even that not very well) but medical “science” can’t change the shape of our pelvises, or the density of our bones and muscles. It can chemically alter a few hormones to act against its “born will” but that doesn’t work out all that well either. And certainly, medicine cannot change every cell in our body to express the male or female chromosome arrangement (whichever one a person was not born with).
[I am using the trans issue as only one example of what we are identifying as “progress.”]
Generally, the reason we accept everything as natural progress is because we have let go of any sort of divine plan. Whatever happens to us is just the way it is, and even if we don’t like the consequences of that deviation from the divine way, we do not fight it, we do not say, “This sucks, this isn’t what is supposed to happen.” At worst, we just throw up our hands and say, “What can we do? Progress is progress; we can’t fight progress.”
That’s the worst-case scenario. That worst-case applies to things like the ill effects of social media, pornography, the mutilation of children in the name of gender identification, the devastation of medical treatments such as chemotherapy, radiation, vaccinations, and bad pharmacology. Some things we do try to change, but the attempt at change is usually top-down, not bottom-up. Top-down is trying to change things like the frequency and duration of cell phone use, for example. Bottom-up is working on the development and healing of the psychology behind the compulsion to stare at a cell phone screen 18 hours out of 24.
The ”less than worst-case” we are just fine with out of the box. We may find some realization that it isn’t ultimately all that good, but we honour the concept of “progress” so passionately we are perfectly fine with it. We also may be totally blinded by progress, particularly if it is of the technological kind, we actually love it and even the consequences of it. Medical technology gets this treatment more often than other examples (entertainment and convenience are a close second).
According to the administrators of medical technology, we live longer, we suffer less, and maybe we even function more efficiently thanks to them. We care very little for things like expense, negative consequences, drug side effects, or physical and psychological dependency.
The advancements of science are always forgiven. Even the progress that made the atomic bomb a viable form of warfare weaponry—“How can you stop progress?” We are victims and slaves to it. Unfortunately, most of the time willingly.
If we lived by a certain human and divine ethic first, we would stop advancement when we could see that it would not be beneficial in achieving our goals as human beings. We would not allow “progress” to rule us and roll over us, taking progress for granted, and as a given, wherever it ends up taking us.
We should have a clear image of what human beings are supposed to be, and work toward that image. We should put the image first, as a priority, and reject anything that comes out of our creative mind that is contrary to it. This should be an individual pursuit and assessment of our personal behaviour in the world—not an action dictated by government or even by the church.
The ancient Egyptians believed that we all individually knew what this image was, in our hearts, and only needed to follow its divine, and wise, guidance.
Todd Hayen PhD is a registered psychotherapist practicing in Toronto, Ontario, Canada. He holds a PhD in depth psychotherapy and an MA in Consciousness Studies. He specializes in Jungian, archetypal, psychology. Todd also writes for his own substack, which you can read here
SUPPORT OFFGUARDIAN
If you enjoy OffG's content, please help us make our monthly fund-raising goal and keep the site alive.
For other ways to donate, including direct-transfer bank details click HERE.
Is it:
A Chick with a dick?
Or:
A bloke with tits?
The answer is clear.
“The 2025 National Citizens Inquiry is live now!
March 6th, 7th and 8th 2025 in Edmonton Alberta.”
“Lay Witnesses and Expert Witnesses including Dr. David Martin, John Carpay, Dr. Wanda Holman, Alex Schadenberg, Dr. Heather Herington, Dr. Kelli Palfy, Dr. Jessica Rose, Dr. David Speicher, Dr. Chris Shoemaker, Del Bigtree, Dr. Mark Trozzi, Dr. Magda Havas, Dr. Robert Chandler and Dr. William Makis will be answering the question, “Are Our Children Safe in Canada?”
We will be documenting where we are today, what is going right and what is going wrong. Our expert witnesses will be testifying about varied topics including M.A.I.D., our education system, child trafficking, vaccines and health, to name but a few.”
https://nationalcitizensinquiry.ca/hearings-2025/
Sherry Widynowski – Mar 06, 2025 – Edmonton, Alberta *REPLAY*
https://rumble.com/v6qcas6-sherry-widynowski-mar-06-2025-edmonton-alberta-replay.html
After listening to the testimony of Sherry Widynowski, for some reason, two songs came to mind; a song from Modern English and Queens of the Stone Age.
I Melt With You
https://youtu.be/LuN6gs0AJls?si=LtNDIwLynAR3-h09
–
You Can’t Quit Me Baby -A cover of QOTSA from Trison Boyes Music
https://youtu.be/TlRQ0tMwCbM?si=mD54r-3OtlY5rr3K
–
Question
How do these two songs relate to the experiences of Sherry Widynoski?
–
Anyways, I’m curious, anyone else watching the 2025 National Citizens Inquiry testimonies?
As they say at the NCI … “The world is watching.”
We all do it (mea culpa). We worry about the wrong things. It won’t be trannies that does our species in, or nukes, or the WEF, or biological agents…
…it’ll be nonsense. I just saw a blurb that Prince Harry’s wife, the lovely Meghan, will have her very own Netflix show about cooking, gardening and, you know, the things your average stay at home (or palace) wife does.
Who wants to bet that it won’t be one of the top rated Netflix shows of all time? Every sheep out there will be glued to their TV (maybe literally?).
You are absolutely right…all the things we think will do us in are essentially symptoms of the nonsense.
“To give you a feel for what this looks like, consider the Inuit of northern Canada. An old woman was interviewed one time and the interviewer asked, “what’s the worst thing that’s ever befallen your people?” This is a deeply indelicate thing to ask somebody from any kind of traditional culture, and it was clear to him that she didn’t know. So he started suggesting things to her. In fact, what she was trying to do was politely avoid answering the question. He kept prompting her and finally she said, “I think it was television.”
The interviewer couldn’t believe television compared to starvation and forced relocation by the government. He said, through the interpreter, “how can you say that television is the worst thing that ever happened?” And she gestured to her grandson, who was sitting in the next room, plastered to the television, of course, and she said, “ever since this thing came, we can’t talk because I can’t talk TV,” by which she meant English.” Stephen Jenkinson
Jul 22 Elderhood: Coming Of Age In Troubled Times / Stephen Jenkinson
https://www.lastborninthewilderness.com/episodes/stephen-jenkinson
–
“Lizzie said she was upset by how people had become so attached to their phones.
“People are treating those phones like they are gods,” she said. “They’re bowing down to it at the table, bowing down to it when they’re walking. Here we say we don’t bow down to idols, and that’s getting dangerously close, I think.”
In Amish Country, the Future Is Calling
By KEVIN GRANVILLE and ASHLEY GILBERTSON
September 17, 2017
https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/15/business/amish-technology.html
–
South Korea
Girl starved to death while parents raised virtual child in online game
Mark Tran
Fri 5 Mar 2010
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2010/mar/05/korean-girl-starved-online-game
–
Stare Into The Lights My Pretties
Documentary film by Jordan Brown
https://archive.org/details/Jore_StareIntoTheLightsMyPretties/StareIntoTheLightsMyPretties_1080p-2652k.mp4
–
About
Stare Into The Lights My Pretties
https://stareintothelightsmypretties.jore.cc/about/
–
“The Social Dilemma film highlights the arrival and exponential growth of social media, and its direct correlation with self-harm and suicide amongst pre-teens and youth: U.S. hospital admissions of girls aged 15-19 have increased 62% since 2009 (correlating with social media becoming accessible via the mobile phone), with the admission of young girls aged 10-14 having increased a staggering 189%. U.S. suicide rates for young girls are just as alarming with a 70% increase for girls aged 15-19 (*compared to the average from 2001-2010), with the suicide rate of the younger group of girls (aged 10-14) increasing a whopping *151%. This tragedy alone should be enough to relegate social media to the dustbin, yet in an “Albright-esque” depravity, society has accepted the self-harm and suicides with the unspoken yet collective “we think the price is worth it” non-response. The corporate world that lies and breathes this depraved ideology never has espoused nor never will espouse a higher regard for humanity than for profits.” Cory Morningstar
It’s Not a Social Dilemma – It’s the Calculated Destruction of the Social [Part I]
https://www.wrongkindofgreen.org/2020/10/28/its-not-a-social-dilemma-its-the-calculated-destruction-of-the-social/
–
A song … for Tristan Harris
“Social change is still just talk
The things you see in urban walks
Should make you sick and lose your lunch
Inside your high-rise diners … ” Blaze Foley
Make the laws, you own the land
You hold them down when you can’t stand
One of these day’s you’ll get yours aplenty
One of these day’s you’ll get yours aplenty
One of these day’s you’ll get yours aplenty …” Blaze Foley
You’ll Get Yours Aplenty
https://youtu.be/AmJhbcpZ3sA?si=zCuE6AC0BKO4wk7P
Internet reality from actual reality.
This doctor is heavily indoctrinated by the alt media.
As a service provider and reality world, I have never meet a man women wanting to use there breast milk to feed a child,
I have never ever meet a trannie trying to convert me or read me a story or any one of the children I work with or friends children’s.
As an real awaken adult, if I want to go to Pride I will and I do not give a fuck if a anyone want to identify as anything.
INFACT I have never ever meet anyone ever who identifies as a what ever, as the christendoom alt media shills as this is real world reality when in fact it is not.
what i have meet is this….
We are only asking you to stay home, and do your performance in closed clubs. Thanks.
We demand the exact same of heterosexual married couples. Stay home and do yr things in yr own bedroom, and make strip tease in closed clubs. Thanks.
Why is it so difficult for you latex people to understand this simple organisation of our society and civilisation?
Way too soon to be touting the virtues of “our society and civilisation.” As scary as the thought of drag queens walking around as if they had a right to is to you, people basing their very limited sens of morality on a set of rules scribbled down thousands of years ago is just as scary to me.
Ok, let us try that one: Do you want to live in a society without morality?
The set of morality rules from thousand years ago consist of 10 simple rules; Not Kill, not Steal, not make Adultery, not make Idols.
Love your God in Heaven Love yr Neighbour.
You call that “very limited”. You prefer drag queens in the streets, and “Papa why are these men dressed as mommy”, and 1 million “other rules” with comprehensive “sense of morality”. Test not passed Howard!
Its the second time you didnt pass the test. One more time not passing the test, you will be kicked out from Paradise for good!
If YHWH is actually the Devil in drag it might be you who is kicked out of paradise for good.
After all the Amalekite children butchered at its command would tell you they can see no difference.
You’d better be careful.
There ARE MEN who get off on abusing their children w moob milk.
THERE ARE troons trying to manipulate children to believe they are “born in the wrong body.
Nobody is attempting to stop you from attending “Pride”.
Whatever you ID as should not be expecting affirmations from everyone.
I AFFIRM NO DELUSIONS.
Everyone is appalled at the level of child abuse perpetrated by religious clergy.
“Drag Qs’ are MEN and thus some, as well as other troons, have been abusing, raping and killing children and women. FACT.
What SERVICE do u provide?
Do you know a seagull ?
Rudimentary Peni – Tower of Strenght
Believe your eyes ?
As a self-confessed ufo observer, I guess they are visible sometimes, hey, the smartest guy in the world (psyop?) thinks so too, if you haven’t seen them, your not paying attention, or live in a city..
Probably just from over theirs..
Ancient Aliens Globes Space Psyop
Beyond The Reset. Animated Short film. (24:08)
Anyway, it’s not easy to imagine liberatory technology because
technology is all about control…
Didnt Pharao time followed Ra the sun god and killed all workers when the pyramid was finished so the secrets didnt ended on the frontpage of The Times?
Anyway I think only religious people understand yr article. I see modern people most and they have some Zzzzz and contempt for all religious matters……with good reason.
But the problem is, religion is the only thing which can explain rationally what happen in our times.
So many people who lost Adam and Eve and Moses in school will also be lost in having at least an answer to the very weird times we live in.
I see it as is described: That Politicians and sheeple in general think they can create reality by changing words or change words meaning (= semantics) without using a hammer or lifting a finger.
Well, lets try Catholic and we apologize to the true believers who also are there but trapped within this organisation:
https://off-guardian.org/2025/03/07/watch-james-corbett-and-friends-deliver-the-white-pill-solutionswatch/#comment-712641
You, presumably, believe that those non “I AM” people under your “religious” umbrella who you think understand this article are gullible a-holes (since they do not believe in the one true deity which happens to have a 3 way split personality disorder).
Now, the non “I AM” group of religious a-holes are given reprieve – their gullibility miraculously provides the power to rationally explain the entire sh*t show.
Or, perhaps, you simply conflate religion with Christianity (no sympathy for the poor Hellenists 😔 )
It’s not simple following the meandering mind of any gullible a-hole.
PS What’s wrong with the “trapped” Catholics, are they still buying indulgences?
There are many variants of the main religions why many people are confused.
The Bible give us again the answer, talk about the true Doos and the false Doos.
Same inside main religions. I know many Catholic nuns who are true believers. therefore I call them trapped inside an failed organisation where the top declare itself holy but are demonic. Let us respect true believers wherever they are.
True Islam is in many ways the same as true Christianity. But also here we find false Islam and false Christianity claiming to be religious but are not.
But, notwithstanding you are false or true religious, you get a more true understanding of our world and situation by having been teach universal basic principles in religious books.
For example the only document where the water cycle is described, is in the Bible. You cant read about it nowhere else, why the water cycle, known all over ME first late came to Europe to Paris around year 1700.
Unclean animals. Health advises. m.m. secrets many religious people know that non-religious people dont know..
Psychopathic, like a fair fraction of its, alleged, creation:
5 Thou shalt not bow down thyself to them, nor serve them: for I the Lord thy God am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers upon the children unto the third and fourth generation of them that hate me;
Yes, and clearly you dont understand this cite. You need an professional to teach you what this mean yes? What I said thereby confirmed!
Something like a professional co-n-vid a-hole Doctor.
I don’t think we need more “religion(s)” but some explorations of spirituality may be in order.
An exploration of spirituality leads you to Christ. That’s a fact.
Sorry off topic, sort of.
We all know the art business has been rigged for decades, but since the ugly emergence of streaming, the music business has also been manipulated into a ruthless form of fakery :
https://spectrumculture.com/2025/02/13/mood-machine-by-liz-pelly-review/
From someone who knows:
https://www.classichits.ie/news/music-news/sam-fender-says-music-industry-is-rigged-and-90-kids-who-are-privately-educated/
Thanks for the thoughtful ruminations Todd , something to take into account though is that Techno Feudalism, is no longer going to be “progressive” but rather its antithesis as personified by the likes of Theil, Musk and Ellison..and the “Dark Maga” gang , the Bait and switch of the last few Decades has in effect reached the the desired techno fascist pinnacle.. either way of course amounts to enslavement of the majority.. Iain Davies great article on Dark Maga is worth anybodies Time… requiring stamina it’s quite a long and demanding albeit stunning exposition !
https://unlimitedhangout.com/2025/03/investigative-series/the-dark-maga-gov-corp-technate-part-1/
Iain Davis not Davies!
Roberta Flack -Trying Times 1970
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=La8_flXOTrI
Thoughtful rumination
Just thought this thing out
Huh
Thoughtful rumination
My head aches, full clout
Thoughtful rumination
That’s it, I’m out
Lu1 is counting the beliefs here !
Excellent stuff. We all count on our beliefs but how many discount beliefs ?
Discount unverified in nature screen images maybe a good starting place, if you believe that, too late now.
Inevitably,
Woods, from the last album, in their top 3,
WOODS – BETWEEN THE PAST (OFFICIAL MUSIC VIDEO)
I believe it wasn’t just the ancient Egyptians who knew that every able-minded human being could intuit that inner guidance to what is right and wrong, or to put it in your terms, what a human being should be. I also believe that peer group pressure is the toxic influence that leads humans astray, as it prevents us from going within, that silent space we need to reconnect with divinity, whatever that may be. To me, it’s the inner knowing that something seems fake or dangerous or the trust in that which appears honest and benevolent.
Your on my level.
Schizophrenics have inner guidance.
“… peer group pressure is the toxic influence …”
Perhaps, but I think it largely depends on the peers.
Peer pressure can also work in exactly the opposite way, if said peers are able-minded individuals who intuit inner guidance. Compatible behaviour is rewarded; incompatible – less so.
We are essentially herd animals and most will gravitate to the herd perceived as being most viable – whatever viable might look like in any given scenario. ‘Society’ is maintained by eliminating the incompatible, either through the encouragement of ‘good’ behaviour or, conversely, the actual elimination of dissenters. The former is preferable.
Herd instinct is (or was) a survival imperative but sadly, when weaponised against us, it could quite conceivably lead to our eventual eradication as, lemming like, we blindly follow the social media influencers over the cliff.
Yep, right on target. When every kid started to get a blue ribbon or gold star NO MATTER WHAT, I knew we were in for trouble. I could not know the unintended consequences but I knew they were coming. And here we are … now, what caused that change? There is a lot in the notion that we dropped religion (God) and replace with science (Technology). Even if that is the driver, why did we do that? Why, why, why … I just can’t help but ask.
Actually, you’re a day late and a dollar short on this blue ribbon/gold star thing. The very idea of beginning a child’s “education” by establishing a hierarchy/meritocracy is the cause of most of our problems today. Every kid getting a ribbon or star is no worse than one kid getting them. Scrap the ribbons and stars and just let kids do what they do best: learn.
A key principle of strength training is “progressive overload.” You must repeatedly suffer the stress of lifting heavier and heavier to improve. But you also need recovery time between sessions.
I feel overloaded with progressivism. But there is no recovery time granted, and no sign of improvement. Just constantly accumulating micro tears in the fibres of society. Soon the ‘muscle’ will be torn completely.
Whenever I see a young person with a tee shirt advising “NO PAIN NO GAIN,” I think to myself “Just wait till you get my age – you’ll have so much GAIN you won’t know what to do with it!”
“..the reason we accept everything as natural progress is because we have let go of any sort of divine plan..”
So true. As Alasdair Campbell once said, “..we don’t do God.”
Without external focus, the most important thing becomes the self. And to stay amused, we keep needing new toys.
It’s time that this Tower of Bollox came crashing down. There’s little to cry over.
You can experience the divine plan or whatever you want to call it in many different ways, but they all demand ‘paying attention,’ to what is actually happening and obviously staring incessantly into a tiny screen kind of gets in the way of the necessary awareness.
It’s staring you in the face but you don’t SEE IT.
Yep. We’ve been truly ensnared. Literally no-one has escaped. A nation of crash-test dummies.
We’ve got a bunch of power-hungry megalomaniacs on the planet trying to control or even extinguish our lives, with a never-ending supply of replacements, and it just keeps getting worse. When my grandkids have kids, my great grandkids will be ruled from birth by those assholes. They will effectively be born slaves. We as a human race on this planet are not progressing. We’re regressing in a way, to the basic human instincts present from the beginning. Survival of the fittest is just around the corner. Freedom and liberty have become obsolete, in the name of progress, and not even discussed now, and when you do, like now, you’ll be looked at as some sort of esoteric dreamer who doesn’t understand reality. Or progress. It’s like freedom and liberty have become nostalgic and obsolete paragons from another time that simply can’t be integrated into today’s world. Maybe the whole purpose of men with tits is to keep us talking, complaining, and disagreeing about the supposed progress while the boiling pot reaches its zenith.
I still to this day, five years down the track, cannot for one moment fathom how of all the elements of COVID, every part of the nonsensical tyrannical fraud they pulled, the biggest, worst and most fundamental part is never ever talked about by anyone, including all those clued up about the reality of it all.
Namely, when the fuck did I ever agree that under any condition I cede my freedom to leave my home and go about my life and business at my own will and leisure?
It was the most heinous part of the COVID assault and the least talked about. April to June 2020 I was walking around Piccadilly, Green Park, Buck House, happy as a sandboy. No mother fucker, ever, under any circumstances tells me when I do or do not leave my home.
99.9% of people just voluntarily locked themselves away like cowering fugitive rats.
Amen. See, that’s righteous.
If you discuss ANY of these issues, most normies will instantly think or say “conspiracy theory.” Or “conspiracy theorist” if they are less polite. (Nice job, CIA. You sure did a number on us, inventing that term. All it took was two words.)
It is truly disheartening that people are so preoccupied with work and the footie that they can’t see what’s staring them in the face.
For sure. The evil tyrants masterminding all this behind the curtains have properly done us all up like kippers.
I’m glad I have my principles. And I’m glad I have my faith and belief in God and a higher purpose to all this.
Democracy is voting every 4-5 years. All galley slaves, now get back to work.
Have you seen news images of the way protestors were treated by the militant police in Melbourne Vic. Aus. when they dared to come onto the streets during lockdown.
I haven’t. I’m sure it’s disgusting.
At the end of a rally here in London circa March 2021, I was leaning against a water fountain in Trafalgar Square (where many of the London marches end at). Most people had already disbanded. Police officers were telling people to move out of the square. One told me to move. I didn’t move or respond. He told me to move again. I didn’t move or respond. He and his colleagues then apprehended me, cuffed me and took me away in a van. I was processed down on Whitehall and released after an hour. I never watch the news, but I had a hunch. Sure enough, that night, the BBC evening news reported some disorderly gathering and all they had to portray the terribleness of it was me being cuffed. I mean, to say the depravity of this world we live in at the institutional level. I wonder to this day if surely it was not possible to sue the BBC for essentially what amounts to defamation of character.
The fine for breaking COVID gathering laws, which are void and defunct in the first place, and even by their own Mickey Mouse standard I wasn’t breaking them anyway (I believe it was a gathering of more than two that was prohibited), never did arrive in the post.
I wish more people loved their freedom. I wish more people cared about the basic moral principles of life.
One of my favourite quotes of all time is that one that goes along the line of: “no person is qualified to govern any other person, least of all those who desire to do so.”
It is at once the most peculiar and damning trait of humanity that 99.9999999999% of people want to be dominated. This trait is the doom of mankind.
It’s funny, in my life people always say to me, you should be in politics (because I’m intelligent, fair minded, an excellent public speaker, and principles based). Yet I have absolutely no desire to be in politics. Zero. For the simple reason that I do not want to govern. I’m Maximus or William Wallace. I just want to live life. Learn. Grow. Love. Travel. Experience all the ups and downs.
Maybe being in 12 step addiction recovery for many years has helped facilitate, albeit in very limited closed environments, the experience of how well humans can strive to foster true fellowship. Maybe that’s pie in the sky and wishful thinking beyond a limited one hour gathering of addicts for a very specific purpose.
And I guess that is why our world will always be fucked. Because there will always be a never ending supply of people that do want to govern and lord it over others.
They al were told they would die if they didn’t, and they believed it.
Sigh… yep. And that’s why I reluctantly accept that salvation (I deliberately use that word in its truest and fullest meaning and not in the religious triggering sense) cannot ever come from humanity.
“Merry England 2.0, the country that emerges after the now inevitable collapse, will be a happy place because the Progressive Delusion will have been destroyed in that collapse. The Myth of Progress will finally be seen for what it is, the product of an Idiot Mind. Things do not get better; it is just a lie that we tell ourselves. They simply change, all the time. Sometimes the changes are enjoyable and beneficial for us, other times they are not, but they are always to learn from. There is no such thing progress. The way of life is up, and then down, and then up and then down. What is called progress is simply a specific political agenda which is presented as inevitable so that you don’t question it. But everything can, and should, and must, be questioned, mocked and derided. The most serious matters, spoken by the most earnest people must be the things that are most laughed at.
Politics is a good example of this, something which is no longer a serious business conducted by serious people. It is a clown show, run by and for fools. In our current, pre-revolutionary state we are not in danger of losing democracy, it has already gone. The people in the Houses of Parliament do not make the laws. They simply codify what has been pre-agreed elsewhere. We can fight against this, pretend it isn’t true, try to get involved to ‘change things’, ignore it altogether, OR WE CAN JUST LAUGH. Politicians are morons and political pundits are imbeciles. These are joke people, not serious or substantial in any respect, and we take our power back from them by laughter and mockery. They would absolutely hate to be thought of as jokers, but that is really what they are. They thrive on being taken seriously and cannot abide being mocked. But that is how they will be defeated.”
Extract from “Merry England 2.0” by Richard Abbot: https://www.thehermitage.org.uk/blog/merry-england
Good article…but easily summed up in one word, Marxism.
No. Scientific materialism.
You know, I don’t think, and correct me if I’m wrong on this, but I don’t think that Karl Marx had an opinion on transgenderism, one way or another.
The shriek of Marxism is one more idiotic hangover from the Cold War, sigh. No thought needed, just bleat “commie” or “Marxist” then lather, rinse, repeat ad nauseum.
Exactly.
Or socialist.
Don’t forget to add in The Conditioner.
‘Rothschild’ would be closer.
‘Rothschild-Bauer’, you got it in one.
As in ; follow the money.
No matter if the paths where it seems to lead seem
‘illogical.’
ps. translation errors:
“over-personalized” -> “suprapersonal”
“space without walls” -> “room without walls”
The concept of progress in the West is really a form of narcissism and insanity. On the other hand, indigenous people who Westerners denigrate as backward or primitive, hold fast to their traditions, honor their ancestors and their relationship with the natural order. Not so in the West.
As the writer points out, our globalist overlords think they are god and like the archetype renegade “Satan” believe they can usurp the natural order, suppress or rechannel the natural frequencies and redirect them into their dystopian agenda. Being immoral, they think they are immune to the consequences of their psychopathy and wickedness. What the writer didn’t mention is transhumanism not just transgender but transhumanism: altering the very make up of humans via gene splicing/tampering, human brain/machine interface, chips implanted into our brains and turning humans into cyborgs, chimeras and hybrids like the mad scientists they are. What these demons fail to realize is, KARMA will have the last word.
Thank you…right on. No, I did not mention transhumanism in this particular article but do very often. Not sure why I passed over it as I believe it is the underlying evil to just about everything else we are seeing.
Read my article on CS Lewis and “That Hideous Strength”…among many other articles that focus on transhumanism…it is definitely one of my primary focuses. Thanks for bringing it up here…
Dr. Hayen my comment was not a criticism, merely a complimentary addition so the readers have some idea of the hell the overlords intend for us. Keep up the great work!
I didn’t take it as a criticism! I was actually perplexed myself why I didn’t go into transhumanism in this particular article!! Thank you!
Thanks, Todd. I think all that you’ve written about Transhumanism is great. Transgender is the speeding train to Transhumanism.
Ppl could also read books of or watch interviews of Jennifer Bilek on Transhumanism.
Actions construed as being facilitated by demons can and should be correctly described as ‘demonic’, and vice versa.
Demonic actions are facilitated by DEMONS, no matter how deceptively they try to cover it up and hide their responsibility.
Political-SPIRITUAL WAR.
Tread carefully.
It feels like just a couple of years ago that I thought that transhumanism was a far-fetched notion that couldn’t become real for at least fifty years.
Oh, wait. It WAS just two years ago. What man-made horrors beyond human comprehension will they dream up in the next two years? And the years after that?
I’ve seen more insanity in the last five years than in the entire fifty years before that. And it’s accelerating. I feel so sorry for future generations.
My dad and mom said the same thing: “We feel so sorry for you children and you future”.
My Grandpa and Grandma said the same: We felt so sorry for yr mom and dad and their future when they were children.
After all this depression lets us have a little humble song: Gracas a la vida. https://yandex.ru/video/preview/17704416914272131881 .
This woke push in to mass negative is to chase ready individuals out of slumber and into positive self change.
Let’s hope there are many more with the courage to delve into the depths of self and find the transformative power that resides within.
Dr. Hayen, we lost the game on day one – that was when we gave someone else, be it “God” or whatever, the “right” to name things. Otherwise, there would be no such nonsense as “progress.” There is no such thing as “progress”; there is only change.
And the very word “change” terrifies humanity. So humanity – the original male and the female assembled from the male’s rib (was it left or right, I can’t remember which) – pleaded with “God” or “Caesar” or Dr. Strangelove perhaps to please bestow upon the ever changing world of human society a more pleasing word.
And – Voila! – it all became “Progress!” (BTW, I love Lewis Black’s thought on the word Voila: if one opens a pack of rubbers and one leaps out and lands perfectly on one’s dick, then he may declare “Voila!”)
What a great point!! (on the word progress, not on the word “voila”!! 🙂 )
The ‘progress’ word was invented by the Bankers handlers to veil their fraud and that the opposite was going on.
In 2006 IPCC (them with global warming bs) found “the weather is a non linear chaotic system impossible to predict”, here comes yr “change”.
Adam named things. God gave him this tasks. Grass basic colour should be named green, the sky colour should be named blue, a lion should be called a lion, and so on and on.
Nothing wrong with that. Fixed.
Not to be overly critical of Adam’s naming skills. But green is not a primary color; so really, he should have called it red (blue was taken by the sky, yellow by the sun). But, heck, he only had a snake to guide him.
Progress would imply that you/we/I know where we’re going.
Not where they are planning.
‘Deus/Dea has a very big conscious machine at HIS/HER disposal.’
I don’t even see the FAT LADY yet.
I think it has less to do with a sense of the divine than the overwhelming need for most humans to stay with the herd, at least with some fork of it, left or right, or some other sub-tribe, and to do with what I have long seen as a natural inclination in most people to choose the lesser of any two options; a lie over the truth; an ugly thing over a beautiful thing, tyranny over freedom, the hive mind over independent critical thought, staring at a phone screen over either an in-person conversation or interacting with nature; preferring an obvious fraud to a sincere man of integrity, etc. We all see this constantly.
The herd has an acceptable Overton Window, the ever-shifting boundaries being determined by the shepherd ownership class (OC) as suits its agenda, and which are easily conveyed to the herd, and the herd members have their instinctive inclination to choose the lesser within that sanctioned area.
Christianity used to be within the sanctioned area in the Western world, and churchgoing would surely cause some minds to ponder the divine, and that’s gone now, but Islam is an Abrahamic religion, too, and widely observed around the world, and I don’t see the choosing of the better or the noble being widely expressed in that culture, either.
I think this is the crux of how and why it all works, and why it’s so easy for the tiny OC to manage and steer the massive herd.
Oh dear – this doesn’t seem to be the “rigorous, fact-checked” journalism the Guardian keep assuring us they are offering. And this is merely today’s Opinion section. Did anyone say ‘conspiracy theorists’?:
“Being Putin’s stooge won’t win Trump a peace prize. The Order of Lenin, though, is in the bag” Simon Tisdall
“Donald Trump is turning America into a mafia state” Jonathan Freedland
“There are 1,000 grotesque memes of JD Vance – and they’re all more likable than the real thing” Marina Hyde
“Andrew Tate is back in the US – and a model of Trump’s worldview” Moira Donegan
Huh? My articles are not “rigorous, fact-checked, journalism”…never have I claimed them to be…they are pure and simply opinion…sometimes funny, and hopefully thought-provoking…take it or leave it.
I picked up and still use various idioms I learned during the previous century, while working in an “inner city” state unemployment office.
The one that comes to mind here is “Don’t ‘C’ yourself into a conversation between ‘A’ and ‘B’.”
But I’m defying this sensible admonition to state, FWIW, that the OP seems to be a complete non sequitur. It references “Guardian” articles, and has no apparent connection or relevance to your commentary.
______________________________________
As long as I’m “here”, although I don’t mean to “C” my way into the larger discussion, I will also mention that I used to buy into the rule of thumb (or more relevant anatomy) that all aspiring and reassigned transexuals were authentic, in the sense that surely they acted from a profound and valid (for lack of a better term) internal gender-identity crisis.
I came to see the trans movement as being hijacked by the overclass exactly as “color revolutions” are staged. There is always a legitimate grassroots core of authentic contrarians, to use a generic term. But eventually powers and principalities move in and hijack the movement, and invariably attract a dubious nouveau group that disproportionately swells the ranks of victims.
Obviously a gender-dysphoria industry was created, fueled by a Woke ideology that eclipsed the “born in the wrong body” rationale and asserted that gender was fundamentally an artificial social construct that individuals were free to manipulate as they saw fit. No, I’m not saying that one can readily judge who is motivated by legacy “wrong body” rationales and who is motivated by ulterior psychological and ego issues; it’s a case-by-case phenomenon.
But once commerce and institutions adopted the fast and loose revisions of what “gender” is, it encouraged all gender-conflicted or confused individuals to jump on the sex-change bandwagon. To put it in personal terms, Renee Richards and Wendy Carlos were not trans “militants” aggressively challenging boundaries of traditional conduct and propriety by insisting on invading gender-segregated spaces and activities.
Many years ago, I had a temporary falling out with a good friend after she derisively, though privately, trashed a co-worker who was allegedly transitioning from male to female. I was appalled, and made almost the exact scathing defense you responded to. But I subsequently learned something that she knew and I didn’t: the transitioning co-worker wasn’t really transitioning at all. He wanted to appear female, and was essentially a full-time transvestite.
Presenting himself as “transitioning” was a novel way of justifying his female appearance– clothing, makeup, wig. For all I know, he may have convinced himself that he was working up to gender-reassignment surgery. But over the months, he never began a transition and gave contradictory reasons to female co-workers– who, BTW, were genuinely sympathetic and curious about how someone made the transition, and solicited progress reports.
I was reminiscing about this situation recently, and had another insight. When I was chastising my friend, I stressed the point that no one would submit to difficult and extensive gender-reassignment surgical procedures on a whim, or fancy. I was outraged at what I perceived as transphobic trivialization.
But since then, something struck me: in the intervening years, extensive body tattooing and body-piercing became all the rage. This forced me to reconsider my assumption that no one would put themselves through excruciating physical ordeals for whimsical or shallow reasons.
Once the fads of inking and piercing gained traction, and essentially marketed physical “enhancements” with social cachet, especially younger people enthusiastically lined up for painful and typically gratuitous procedures; in part, they had become in-group status symbols.
I deplore the rise in vile knee-jerk homophobia, transphobia, etc. that’s emerged as a reaction to the escalated trans profile, but the whole question has become complicated, and is no longer amenable to binary “pro” vs. “con” stances. ⚧️ 🤔
And now there’s an alleged murderer radicalised on-line by Andrew Tate….
That’s at least three agenda items covered by one story – exemplary function-stacking.
TBC Tate is repulsive and it’s only the media now shrieking about him who’ve made him into someone they could then knock down. No “dynamic silence” when it comes to Tate!
The Guardian may be assuring their readers of that, but this is, first, The Off-Guardian, not The Guardian, and, second, it’s an opinion commentary, so you’re comment is entirely irrelevant. Why post that, I wonder? It’s so off. Maybe a bot?
Satanic influence on a faithless population..
I think I am beginning to believe this as well.
And another.
LIKEWISE
The demons have less and less power if we don’t give it to them or let them steal it.
Well, Todd, the primary question if not purpose, is to find out, if possible, ‘why we are here, at this particular time, in this ‘best of all possible worlds.’
AKA: ‘we’re here to find out why we’re here.’
And act on our findings.
Another one.
Arbrhamic religion is that.
Thank you for this post doctor Hayden. As a long retired clinical social worker who has taken a deep dive over the last three years into what is happening in the name of “affirming” gender “identity” – I must say we have moved beyond “Orwellian” and the situation is now quite rather Kafkaesque.
At 73 years of age, and deeply influenced by second wave feminists and their hard won efforts to create women’s rape shelters and women’s domestic violence shelters, and to allow women the experience of sports competition – I really thought the sex based “gender-stereotypes” of the past had been put to bed for good – and that all were now free – regardless of biological sex to simply be who we are. What a surprise to watch the “gender-ideologues” pull those tired old gender stereotypes and tropes out of the dustbin of history, dust them off, and insist that they actually posses “magical” powers and are “more real” than the biology between one’s legs. Who would have guessed that lipstick and a blond wig is more “real” than female genitalia? As a former child protection worker I will offer no quarter to adults who support the mutilation of children in service to their internal fantasy worlds – and who encourage children to embrace and share this fantasy world with them to the physical and emotional detriment of those children.
The gender-cult feels very much like past end-times social contagions. A sort of a “Judith Butler meets Saint Vitus Dance” vibe emanates from the completely “reality-detached” foaming at the mouth expectation that all must “believe as we do” or be branded “heretics” deserving of the stake.
If somehow the West survives this current madness and finds courage to reflect upon it – the gender ideology movement and all the surgical and chemical mutilation and castration of young people consumed by it – will make the past “lobotomy” scandal look relatively insignificant.
Thanks again for addressing this topic – protected from scrutiny far too long by the fatuous irrational and unscientific “virtue-signaling” of the truth believers and the cowardice of those too fearful to dare raise a voice to protect children if it might risk tarnishing their precious “identity” as a supposed “progressive.”
Yes, this is the 21st Century version.
The crunch is more or less HERE.
Nothing much seems to have changed except the technology.
Witches and Joan of Arc are still being burned, and the minor details of being de-platformed are mere irritants compare with that sort of treatment.
I wonder if you know any transgender people, Dr Hayen, PhD?
I do.
I finally stopped replying to all of the heartless, ignorant (harsh word but apt) posts and comments about transgender people over the past 5 years. Articles by medical freedom advocates and Health Freedom commenters that I would have thought had more compassion and more common sense then to fall for the obvious mainstream agenda to vilify and scapegoat yet another group.
Normally, now, when I see the vitriol coming I just skip over and don’t read. Live and let live.
But sometimes it just gets the better of me.
While I respect your right to your own opinion, and while I respect the right of Offg to print whatever they choose, I am deeply, deeply saddened at this essay.
Transgender people do not wake up one day and decide to change their sex on a whim. it is an arduous, and I would say courageous journey. They are not thinking about “progress” or the “worse case scenarios” and “the less than worst case scenarios”.
While I respect that they are your opinions, I find your description both inaccurate and deeply insulting.
To conflate bathroom issues and sports participation with the personal issue of being transgender is wrong. To conflate the personal issue of being a transgender with doctors giving out hormone changing drugs to children is wrong. It’s like calling people that won’t get jabbed “granny killers”.
Mainstream media, with the usual powers that be at the helm, have done a marvelous job at muddying the waters.
While prayer is a daily constant in my life, as is my own belief in the divine, I do not for one minute presume to think that I know what God has in mind for humanity or the universe in general. How arrogant to even presume.
I guess my idea of what a human “is supposed to be” and your idea of what a human “is supposed to be” are quite a bit different.
“Individual pursuit and the assessment of personal behavior”. Absolutely.
I wager most transgender feel the same.
(This is an essay I would expect to read in the New York Times.)
Yes, I know transgender people. My comments in my articles may seem harsh, and at times are harsh, on many levels. And at times I do “make fun” or “make light” of serious issues to make a point. My gripe with transgenderism and transsexualism is aimed primarily at the people and institutions surrounding these people encouraging them to make radical physical changes. I also have issues with radical groups who make every effort to bring innocent children into their fold through social pressure and coercion.
I understand the psychological implications of people who feel a strong, very strong, compulsion to “be something they are not”. I have seen them in my practice, and I treat them as I do any other client, with compassion, understanding, empathy, and love.
Humans have very difficult situations they face in life. We must always show compassion and empathy, but when their emotional and psychological compulsions cause harm to others, or cause others to coerce them and take advantage of their situation in order to monetize it for their own benefit, a different approach is required.
I am sorry that I appear to be a callous jerk…at times I definitely fit that description. When I was writing this I was thinking of all of the kids who have been physically and psychologically damaged for life because they were encouraged to “do whatever they felt like” …I am sorry, I do not agree that the majority of these people are dealing with something that is so deeply seated in their being they do not have choices regarding their identifications some do not, I am sure, but most do have choices, but the culture pushes them to the brink and beyond.
‘fess up doc. Anti-trans is simply the new homophobia.
Fascist ‘freedom’ dreams are always selfish. Funny really, exactly what they/you accuse the opposion of.
Lotta hatespeech round these parts.
Your comment ignores the gist of the essay I think. Our highly manufactured culture that elevates impossibilities over obvious reality (humans are either male or female, men can not give birth, etc.) has not only muddled critical thinking, its undermined trust in the Natural world – which humans are part of. As if there is no intelligence behind life. As if everything can be a mistake that humans need to fix. Talk about hubris.
I can appreciate and feel for someone born one sex who feels more aligned to another. And I have no problem with them. But that doesn’t mean I don’t see the massive propaganda push out there to convince impressionable young people that basic life can not be trusted.
Changing your physical body to accommodate that feeling of ‘wrong-gender’ is extreme. If a fully grown adult wants to do that – and take the risks, okay.
However there has been an intentional push to get children to question to doubt themselves. To mutilate their bodies. Higher suicide rates and depression among those who go through transgender surgeries is not surprising then.It’s nothing short of child-abuse.
And, as the essay points out, that’s just one area of fabricated reality-spinning we’ve been dealing with. Everything has been turned on its head under the woke agenda and it’s kind of insane that we even have to undo certain givens.
In such a distorted terrain, in such a highly propagandized environment, accurate self-assessment is hardly a given. If you want evidence just look at how many people trusted government and Big Pharma during Covid (throwing history out) and not only stood in line to take an experimental jab but then felt compelled to post it on social media and value-signal about it? That was insane. That was irrational.
That’s the terrain we’ve been living in.
Wow! I wish my own reply was as eloquent as yours is!
Correct gramma is third person neutral when we are in public domain.
Saying criticizing transgender is not criticizing any person personally, but the political concept and the ugly political actions around it.
Same with gay. Not criticizing gays in person but the f…finger is to the political focus, promotion and rights concept around it, constantly in the media.
I already made one lengthy response to this comment, but I am compelled to make a few more! Let’s see if this is the last.
First of all, this is a very intelligent and well written response, with some very important points. Thank you for taking the time to write it.
Here is a comment you make: “Transgender people do not wake up one day and decide to change their sex on a whim.” I would agree with the general point you make here, I agree it is not “that simple,” just as any form of psychosis is not simple (if being pressured by a social contagion ranks as psychosis or just immature infatuation with a peer group). Psychosis is a departure from reality and comes in a wide spectrum of presentations, from believing there are little green men in the backyard to being certain you are not who or what you really are.
Not ALL people dealing with a dysphoric identification of gender are diagnosable psychotic, but many have sunk into that terrifying psychological state of grappling with reality. I do believe this, and the only thing that would convince me otherwise is a study that proves gender identification to be a new form of psychological state that does not include a dysphoric element to it, nor a psychotic one.
As it stands now, it is no more psychologically normal than someone who identifies as a rodent. It certainly is more compelling and more common and has more legitimate basis seated in human archetypal constellation, but it is not psychologically normal to pursue it to a point where physiological and hormonal alterations are deemed necessary for survival—for the majority of cases, not all of them.
And this is just my opinion, but I share it with many doctors, psychiatrists, and psychologists. And just for the record, I am not saying that gender identification is psychotic in a clinical fashion, but it could be, and could be a form of psychosis and is more apt to lead to serious psychotic issues. This is a very complex situation psychologically, and my articles rarely step into this area of discussion, they stick with the culture’s response to transgenderism, and particularly transexualism. Not the individuals themselves suffering what I believe to be a psychological abnormality…for MOST but not ALL situations.
People who identify as the opposite sex to what they were born with and do not have problems dealing with it (other than social communal problems of acceptance and tolerance—which is to be expected for anyone who deviates from the consensus) would not fall under a psychological pathology (in my opinion). They are no different psychologically than someone who identifies as an artist, a musician, or an accountant. I am not writing about these people. The identification with feminine or masculine archetypal energies is common during any healthy human’s life. This is normal, and healthy.
Your comment about conflation…I do not believe I conflate the way you describe, I believe the culture does. And yes, that is a problem.
I have issue with this following comment, but my issue is only a curiosity and nothing serious, “I do not for one minute presume to think that I know what God has in mind for humanity or the universe in general. How arrogant to even presume.” I doubt very seriously if you do not “presume to think” that you know what God has in mind for humanity. Anyone who is not an atheist has some sort of presumption as to what God wants of them and wants of humanity and the universe, otherwise they would be an atheist who believes all of this is arbitrary and random based only on matieral cause and effect.
You might not be correct, your presumption may be very flexible and all incompassing, and you might not care if everyone believes as you do. But you cannot believe in a higher power without having some idea as to how to live your life in accordance with that higher power’s “vision.”
As I, you may not be able to put this presumption into words. But you making a comment as you have on my article is very clear you believe in SOMETHING regarding how things SHOULD BE…you clearly do not believe what I think is correct or “right”…so you presume what you think IS right and correct…and if you believe in God, and believe you follow, to some degree, God’s will and vision, then you presume you know what God wants for you and for humanity. Otherwise you wouldn’t care at all what I think and write, and/or you would not believe in a higher power.
Dr. Hayen,
Thank you for your very thoughtful replies.
I would reply to each and every point were this just between the two of us but I will spare Admin, the staff and the readers of Offg any further argument from me.
I do not share your beliefs about transgender, but they are yours and so be it.
I am just dismayed, astonished and initially angry when I read articles that paint what I consider the wrong picture. I do not know any transgender people that coerce, groom, or otherwise encourage young children to take puberty blockers. I believe that is a media story to encourage more distraction and hate.
The transgender people I know have families and jobs and interests and hobbies. And just want to live their lives, like the rest of us perfect, normal heterosexuals.
Thank you, again, for your reply.
I wonder what we are to think when someone is induced by the media and the people around her to think that she is irremediably transgender, when, had she not been exposed to such media and neighbors, the idea would never have crossed her mind?
You may very well be correct about the nefarious media intentions. Again, I have no issues with trans people per se. I am not sure if there is no one in that group who are not guilty of coercion, but I would not be surprised if that number is very tiny, and I would be pretty certain the agenda is behind all of it.
Sorry; but what Dr. Hayen is describing in this article is a reflection of decades of social-cum-political-cum-educational-cum-technological engineering; with, at the very least, two authors explicating the exact history of said phenomenon in their respective works (i.e., see: Scott Howard’s, ‘The Transgender-Industrial Complex’; and Lancing’s & Lindsay’s, ‘The Queering of the American Child’). Only subsequent to perusing and pondering on said theses of the 2 writers noted above will one comprehend the sinister nature of the transgender movement; until then one will remain completely ignorant of the essence of the agenda in question. That is all! RGB-Y5 out!!
Thank you
Do us a favor and don’t reply here either!
“ignorant (harsh word but apt) posts”
You complain about ignorance yet you affirm the opinions of those who deny that they are what they are. How odd.
Does God, whatever God is, ‘intend our sex’? I doubt it.
Our gender is just a random thing, or maybe something to do with cosmic justice (karma).
Believing you ARE God, whatever God is, is a far cry from realising or knowing God.
As many teachers and sages will testify, realising God is the most humbling experience a human can have.
The sex/gender we each are, in each lifetime, is NOT merely a random thing: we each of us (prior to coming to Earth; ie, whilst still in the very real Spirit dimension) plan/decide, for each of our eternal soul’s many, many lifetimes (for most souls, the number of lifetimes will be thousands…), which sex/gender we will be, in each of those lifetimes. Each and every soul lives some lifetimes as male, and other lifetimes as female.
This is how it’s meant to be: for each and every soul has to experience literally everything in life. Which is precisely why each and every soul lives many, many lifetimes: in order to be able to experience everything, from every perspective, in a multitude of different scenarios. We each plan, before coming here, in which country we’ll be born, when we’ll be born, to which parents (yes, we all plan/decide/choose the souls who will be our parents [people who are adopted plan before birth for that to happen; there are always karmic links between the souls which are the biological parents, the adoptive parents, and the adopted child), etc etc etc.
There is no evidence that the reincarntion of spirits/souls is agreed upon and consensual.
There are thousands of near death experiences (NDEs) who testify to being coecred to reincarnate to learn new lessons. Coercion is not consent. This coercion forms the basis of belief that we live in a soul reincarnation trap (trick).
I am not for one minute convinced a spirit would agree to reincarnate to the Earth plane in order to live a life of suffering and misery in human (or animal) form. The New Age (sewage), love and light, useful idiots believe that a spirit entering the world as a child chose to live in or with ANY of the following conditions: hunger, in a war zone, disabled, in a wheelchair, debilitating disease, sexual abuse etc.
I challenge you to walk upto a child in a wheelchair and tell him/her that he/she chose that life. That is victim blaming.
The whole New Age movement is a co-opted psyop that benefits the controllers. All the world’s ills are our fault because we chose to reincarnate here to face whatever difficulties (not matter how awful) we may encounter in our lives.
Also, ALL of these reincarnations occur with a memory wipe each time. Thousands and thousands of lifetimes for some. Not very easy to learn lessons and correct past mistakes when one cannot remember anything. Having to start from zero, learning to walk and talk, let alone more esoteric learning.
I ask you once again, from your hundreds of books, which you always mention, where is the 100 percent PROOF that we chose VOLUNTARILY to reincarnate?
Show me that EVIDENCE and PROVE to me that the subjects (in spirit form) are not deceived and coerced to reincarnate?
Show me the PROOF that the subjects are told before head and agree to return to return to suffer in any of the above mentioned ways?
I’ve not been online since my post of yesterday, so have only just seen your reply.
You and I have ‘crossed swords’ re. this before now. I am NOT going to repeat in this post what I’ve said in earlier ones.
If you truly do not understand that it’s vital that we (as the eternal souls that we each are) go through a ‘veil of amnesia’ before each ‘subsequent’ lifetime (N.B., in truth, all lives are lived simultaneously, for ‘time’ [as we perceive it on Earth] does not exist. We each experience each lifetime separately, linearly, yes, but they do all take place simultaneously), then you do not understand the basics.
Since I began to learn (in this lifetime), as of 1994, the truth of survival of physical body death, I’ve read 1000+ high-quality, scholarly books on the truth of survival. And I correctly state (in my posts on this subject) that there are many tens of THOUSANDS of books published on this topic, NOT merely ‘hundreds’; in your posts to me on this, you repeatedly claim that I refer to mere ‘hundreds’ [of books]. NO, I very correctly state that there are many tens of THOUSANDS [and possibly hundreds of thousands, if one factors in that there will be books on this subject in many other languages too] of books on this vital truth of existence.
Since 1994 I’ve read 1000+ on this subject, and own 400+ on this topic.
Moreover, I’ve read many books on the NDE, and never once I have read any account by someone who claimed that they were coerced into living another lifetime. You are claiming that you’ve read ‘thousands’ of such accounts… hmm…
And NO, if someone told a person in a wheelchair (or someone else in a difficult lifetime) that they’d chosen that for this lifetime, that would NOT be ‘victim-blaming’. It would be telling the truth. No-one is a ‘victim’, whatever ‘adverse’ situation in life people may be experiencing.
There are uncountable numbers of accounts by people who relate that they discussed/decided/chose to reincarnate in order to experience whatever ‘adverse’ situation in their ‘next’ lifetime.
It sounds as if you have an agenda, in ridiculing what are known spiritual truths.
I will not engage with you again on this.
A P.S. to my reply to you of a few mins ago.
You WRONGLY claimed that you’ve read ‘thousands of NDE accounts’ where people say they were ‘coerced’ into another lifetime. Well, excuse me, but in NDEs people do NOT have someone in the Spirit dimension talking to them re. future lifetimes!! The latter happens when we’re each back in the Spirit realms. So you are making a false statement when you claim that there are ‘thousands of NDEs’ where people are ‘coerced’ into having another lifetime.
I have not claimed to have read or watched thousands of NDEs. I have watched perhaps hundreds but there are thousands out there.
If you had watched enough NDE video and/or written testimonies then you would know that people claim to have been approached by entities in the spirit realm claiming to be angels, dead relatives, Jesus Christ, Archangel Michael and so forth. Also claiming to be spirit guides, or other entities that inhabit the astral plane. The astral plane iteself could well be part of this ‘Matrix’ and during these experiences NDEers are coerced to return to the Earth plane by being told they need to return to learn more or they have a special mission on Earth. It is as if they are unworthy to remain in the spirit world. It is a common theme.
https://near-death.com/you-are-not-ready/
The memory wipe makes no sense…it is nonsense. One would learn more by retaining memory. Every tried to do an exam if you lost all knowledge of the subject you studied for? If this a school as you believe , yet seem unable to prove, then it is a strange school.
As far as an agenda, my agenda is to discover/uncover the truth. Meanwhile, you are stuck in New Age programming. Yours is a belief system yet you sell it as fact. Accept it is a belief just as mine currently is. I do not claim to have all the answers, yet you do.
I once believed similar to yourself, however, it is now clear to me that the balance of probability suggest it is a lie and a misdirection. The ‘tunnel of light’ seems to be the key to the trick and the ‘love bomb’ – a feeling of overwhelming love – which causes people to be susceptible to being tricked.
Once again, for the third time, tell me in which book(s), of your thousands that you have read, I can find information regarding the questions that I
have asked.
Tony Sayer’s channel has some interesting NDE analysis and also reviews of New Ager channels and videos.
https://m.youtube.com/@TonySayers/videos
Somehow, I think you will, but will not answer my questions.
You are misunderstanding what is being said when people have an NDE and are told that they have to return to Earth! THAT is when it’s not that person’s pre-destined time to return to the Spirit world, and hence someone in the Spirit realm tells them that “It’s not your time, you have to return to Earth”.
THAT is not the NDE’r being told that they ‘have’ to return to Earth for another incarnation. Which is what you are misunderstanding.
Re. WE OURSELVES pre-planning, before coming to Earth, the major events in each lifetime:
It seems that you ‘think’ that the hierarchy of spirit beings in the Afterlife are evil, deceitful…!! Well, if there’s anything more despicably audacious to claim than that, of those in the Spirit realms, I’ve yet to hear it!!
Some of the many tens of thousands of excellent, high-quality, scholarly books on the truth of the fact that we pre-plan, before coming to Earth (and to other physical planets in the multi-dimensional cosmos, too) are the following:
“Courageous souls: do we plan our life challenges before birth?”, by Robert Schwartz.
“Your Soul’s plan: discovering the real meaning of the life you planned before you were born”, by Robert Schwartz.
“Your Soul’s Gift: the healing power of the life you planned before you were born”, by Robert Schwartz.
“Your Soul’s love: living the love you planned before you were born”, by Robert Schwartz.
“Your Eternal Self: Science discovers the Afterlife”, by R Craig Hogan.
“Reasons for what happens to you in your life & [in] your Afterlife”, by R Craig Hogan.
“Evidence beyond a reasonable doubt [that] you will never die”, by R Craig Hogan.
I repeat here what I said a few weeks ago: that I never cease to be stunned at the lack of intelligence of those who choose (due to their lack of knowledge, and their closed-mindedness) to thumb-down posts (of mine, on this subject) which state 100% factual truths.
A day will come for every one of you uninformed people when you will each have to face that it was you who were wrong, and not me.
Being is NOW.
Not yesterday or tomorrow or in some future ‘incarnation’.
All the literature on past and future lives detracts and distracts from the here and now.
I most certainly do not agree with your stance. People need to know the true nature of existence. The referred-to literature most certainly does NOT ‘detract and distract’ from the here and now.
Countless millions of people around the world DO want to know the actual, factual truths of existence. It provides them with context for living. And the knowledge that we’ve all lived many, many lifetimes (and will live many, many more) gives further context, enabling understanding of why we each experience the things we do, and why we are with certain people in each lifetime (in most lifetimes, we reincarnate with many of the same souls with whom we’ve shared ‘previous’ lifetimes [see my reply to ‘Rolling Rock’ re. why I put the word ‘previous’ in quote marks]), where we each play different roles, in each lifetime. So, for eg, one’s spouse in one lifetime may have been one’s child, or one’s parent, or one’s sibling, or one’s grandparent, in a previous lifetime. What I said in that last sentence is a 100% factual known spiritual truth.
Love and Truth are not in the past or the future.
Past and future are memories and projections of our devious minds.
Love and Truth are here and now.
Where could they be?
Promising heaven, paradise or eternal Life only serves to sully the Truth.
You will get such a big shock on the eventual day on which you do what is so very incorrectly termed ‘die’. Telling the truth re. the very real fact of everyone’s survival of physical body death is doing the exact opposite of ‘sullying the truth’!!
For survival of physical body ‘death’ IS the truth. As you will, one day, find out [at your deepest soul level you are fully aware of its truth; everyone is aware of its truth at their deepest soul level].
The truth is that we do NOT return to ‘heaven’ or ‘paradise’ (they being merely religious words), the truth is that we all return (over and over and over again) to the very real Spirit realms/Spirit dimension [of this multi-dimensional cosmos]: that being our actual ‘place’ of origin.
Countless millions of people around the world are spiritually-aware; ie, they are fully aware of the actual nature of existence: that we (each and every one of us) are eternal souls [ie, spirit beings] who live many, many lifetimes.
My longtime partner, Jim (he returned to the Spirit dimension in March 2019, age 70), on the surface ridiculed the survival of ‘death’ truth.
When he and I met (in this lifetime) in 2001, he was, on the surface, a sceptic, and (mildly) ridiculed what I told him re. the truth. However, deep down, he was aware of its very real truth. In 2005, he told me of an incident which he’d experienced some years before he and I met: that one day he’d seen a spirit child run down the pathway of his then home, and then “disappear into thin air” in the hedge at the bottom of the garden of his then home.
Two of his three sisters in this lifetime are mediums; they both head up one of the many Spiritualist Churches here in the UK.
Our sex is not random if you have an ounce of knowledge about human biology.
I thought it was random, from a human biology perspective, since the sperm carry roughly equal X and Y chromosomes, and which sperm succeeds in fertilising the egg is impossible to predict. That seems like the definition of random. A2
From a materialist perspective (and I am NOT saying you are a materialist!) the randomness of sex selection, as you describe, is certainly a truth. From a metaphysical perspective, pretty much nothing is random. Even though it may appear so, there is a divine intention behind everything.
With Divine Intelligence teleological forethought nothing is random even if we fail to see the meaning and purpose in it.
Revenge of the tooth fairy.
“A non-linear chaotic self regulating system not possible to predict more than 1-2 weeks ahead”.
I love this sentence from IPCC about the weather because it shows they finally reached the right conclusion, off course not to the public, but in an internal report in 2006.
All of life begins as female. Starting at 8 weeks gestation, an embryo with a Y-chromosome produces a factor known as SRY that simultaneously causes the gonads to begin maturing as testes and prevents them from maturing as ovaries. The testes, in turn, produce two important hormones: testosterone and anti-Mullerian Hormone, or AMH. In males, the testes starts producing and releasing testosterone by 10 weeks. Testosterone allows the primitive male anatomy to mature, while AMH causes the primitive female structures to shrivel.
A different view:
‘Modern science thinks of the gonads being like a blank slate to start. The gonads then develop into testes and ovaries depending on genetic factors including, but not limited to, the presence of a Y chromosome.‘
More here:
https://factmyth.com/factoids/all-mammals-start-as-female/
Thanks for that. Then perhaps it’s like the old view of receptor and substrate / lock & key vs the modern view of hand in glove…
One unit. Precisely as I and the Bible says. Lock and key are One unit. Man and woman are One unit, hand and glove are One, m.m.
Nobody are more important than the other because they belong together.
Since when do facts affect the narrative…
When the Tsar bomb exploded.
Another of Trump’s fine Executive Orders. There is two and only two genders in America!
In the Bible you will find that man and woman become One unit in a marriage, and this unit can only be separated by God. See how simple life is when you are religious.
Life WAS simple, until religion came along.
Priests, Mullahs, Bibles, Korans, absurdly ornate temples and churches, fear of sin and hell, millions of words and prayers, rule by iron fists, holy wars (there’s an oxymoron for you) and the money to be made: Billions upon billions.
Religion?
A curse on humanity.
Actually I agree. But as written before we differ between false religion and true religion. To be religious or not to be.
There is nothing wrong with the scriptures if you understand to read up on their symbolic and true nature.
But organised religion which exploit and sucks on the scriptures true nature for political purposes is a curse on humanity.
I once met a moslim in a taxi who was in doubt about the whole thing in his religion and asked me what I think.
I told him to see the church as only an help organisation who promote knowledge about the scriptures, but that the connection to God must be directly between him and God, without the church.
This way he can overcome all the bs in our politicised churches and its failures.