Nothing to Say, Ma
Diego Sandoval
As a result of recent conversations, my life-long closest friend Diego wrote the following. If you’re lucky as we are, you have such a friend whose interests and thoughts match yours so closely that it seems that you were separated at birth in a dream. We both felt from the days of our youth when chance brought us together that, to paraphrase Bob Dylan, it was not he, she, them, or it that we belonged to, or that we would ever gargle in the rat race choir for those who make the rules to terrorize humanity. – Edward Curtin
“Does anybody ever say anything?”
“Not really. Everybody talks all his life, and many write for many years, but nobody really says anything. It’s all right, though.”
William Saroyan, Not Dying: A Memoir
Because I have nothing to say, I am writing this. It’s all right. I have nothing to say because I am disgusted by all the words I have written for deaf ears and by the news that just repeats itself like an endless Greek tragedy to the chorus of commentators of all persuasions echoing each other as if their words made a difference in the butcher’s bench world of ruthless actors with their motto: acta non verba.
I’m just sighing, Ma, like another man of many words, Bob Dylan:
And if my thought-dreams could be seen
They’d probably put my head in a guillotine
But it’s alright, Ma, it’s life, and life only
Life? Yes, Dylan is right: “If you’re not busy being born you’re busy dying.”
But what difference can words make? I don’t know. Quén sabe?
William Saroyan was a witty man, a Pulitzer Prize and Academy Award winner, very famous in his day, and he didn’t know either. He claimed he wrote to ward off death and said he expected an exception to death would be made in his case. He was a man hiding in a house of words, always ready to bolt when death came knocking. But he never grasped the contradictory meanings of bolting, a common neurosis and a necrophiliac’s dilemma.
He wanted to escape death’s clutches but wasn’t sure whether to run or hide. To bolt or bolt, that is the question he couldn’t answer unequivocally. He decided to obsessively accumulate stuff to barricade the entrance to his soul while writing the opposite. His monitory words insinuated the ineluctable nature of his rat packing.
I have spent my life shedding possessions – call it rat unpacking – having seen too many people possessed by them, and the nothingness of death that they represent. I always sensed that nothing is more real than nothing. Having grown up in Mexico – the country that Octavio Paz referred to as the land of the labyrinth of solitude, the country where death lays heavy on every heart, faithful or doubting, I became a poet, writer, and singer to somehow create a language that would lead me into the realm of silence where true language lives and death is exorcised.
I took the stage name Mr. Z to honor my heroes, Zapata and Zarathustra. Perhaps you’ve heard of me. Few who come to hear me perform know my name’s origins and I never explain. Explain to whom? Why?
I was drawn to William Saroyan’s writing at an early age, probably because of his early efforts to write musically and exorcise the death-themed experiences of his childhood with Armenian immigrant parents, his father being a preacher who died when William was three years-old and he was sent to an orphanage along with his sister and brother.
When I was about seventeen years-old I read his first book, The Daring Young Man on the Flying Trapeze, and was mesmerized, especially by his story, “1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8” – its free form musicality with its gaps of silence that tore out my heart.
I identified with the story’s protagonist, who was lonely Saroyan at 19 years of age, and how a few chords in a piece of music, even bad music, transported him into ecstatic reveries, even during moments of silence when he wasn’t listening to the record. I memorized this sentence:
“He stood over his phonograph, thinking of its silence, and his own silence, the fear in himself to make a noise, to declare his existence.”
And then a string of few words came to me – “the music of forgetting” – which have haunted me ever since.
I too hear some secret music and don’t know why I am writing this. I’m only sighing as I move to the music of forgetting.
For his part, Saroyan, in his abodes of death, eventually wrote many millions of words in maybe seventy-five published and unpublished books, saying nothing about something for someone. It was all right, though, I guess he too was only sighing. A kind of sighing that was a haunting.
Aren’t we all sighing? Isn’t the world news enough to haunt anyone with a heart?
Then he died in 1982 at the age of seventy-two. No exception was made for Billy Boy. He either was or wasn’t surprised, depending on what happens when one dies. He said that in everyone’s secret religion “the idea is to keep death at a distance by means of junk of all kinds, and this junk makes a shambles.”
Money, possessions in general, the more junk one can surround oneself with the safer one feels, so that death will have a tough time getting through the clutter to reach you, and in a writer’s case, his most treasured junk – his writing – may be useful in buying death off. This Saroyan said.
When he died, he left two houses in Fresno, California stuffed with shambles. Possessions so junky that they rattle the mind: envelopes of his old mustache clippings, pebbles, rocks, used typewriter ribbons, broken clocks, boxes of junk mail, every piece of ephemera that passed through his grasping hands. He let go of nothing while writing words warning of its futility despite its seeming necessity. He created a foundation in his own name, devoted to the study of himself, to which he left all his junk and to which he bequeathed all future earnings, despite having two children. He thought he was immortalizing himself under the illusion that his shambling rambling words and ratty belongings would free him from the labyrinth of solitude he was leaving. It was not a fit ending for a man who was once the daring young man on the flying trapeze.
Without faith, daring ends in desperate measures. I think Saroyan lost faith in the living.
He forgot his own wise words in the preface to the first edition of his first book:
If you will remember that living people are as good as dead, you will be able to perceive much that is very funny in their conduct that you perhaps might never have thought of perceiving if you did not believe that they were as good as dead.
Isn’t it funny that he left a shambles at home?
Madre, I’m running out of words. Please take my sighs and make them prayers of resistance to the ruthless actors who make this earth our home a bloody shambles.
SUPPORT OFFGUARDIAN
If you enjoy OffG's content, please help us make our monthly fund-raising goal and keep the site alive.
For other ways to donate, including direct-transfer bank details click HERE.





“wisdom above the outworn heart and the eager heart”
A.E.
I read so much non-fiction i forgot how meaningful and poignant it feels to read art like this
Oh I loove your name
Hi Folks/admin, l keep getting a blank page with just a heading when trying to access your site. Can you explain or rectify that?
This message was written on another device.
Maybe they are having a tea break in GCHQ?
I received a notice from Jerusalem Post that I my IP address had become blocked and never again in this life my IP address would be allowed to enter JP. One week later I tried again and no problem.
I believe ‘red lester’ is right. GCHQ or MI6 are on summer holiday or something similar.
Hey I got it: Our IT system is about to be upgraded. Windows 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,910…..yes?
The US government has placed Security Forces on Full Alert today
as Baby Killer Benny is dropping into the Whitehouse for a cuppa
and some chinwag about some very valuable real estate in his
neighbourhood, soon to be available…
thank you for this beautiful meditation on our situation here in this strange world!
personally I believe that every single human being deserves a foundation devoted to the study of his or her particular, inimitably precious essence, which we take for granted, unless it’s some great totem of historical memory like Mozart or Einstein, declared by the Authorities to be Immortal Geniuses, it almost seems, to rub our noses in the supercilious contempt They have for the rest of the population by comparison
for instance, I want there to be a foundation dedicated to the difficult life of my mother, lit up here and there by brief flashes of happiness but mostly filled with grueling sacrifice, trudging along stoically and in large part alone, with a dim hope of some calm and fulfilment in those final golden years, maybe involving long hikes through the forests of US National Parks she cherished, but that hoped-for respite was stolen from her by the disease that carried her off before she even reached the point of retirement
she also collected an apartment’s worth of personal relics, including the stylish dresses of her youth that she knew she’d never wear again, but somehow felt comforted by the idea of still possessing, and reams and reams of newspaper clippings she’d cut out or handwritten synopses she’d produced of TV broadcasts she thought were valuable somehow, as material for further study, to discuss with me or to help her make sense by herself, ultimately, of her own puzzling existence
“living people are as good as dead”, how true! don’t wait until they’re gone to appreciate them
‘Einstein was a Science Fantasy (SF) author’… (popular bumper sticker)
I loved it to death. I couldn’t get the album in London at the time, I could and did get it in New York. And I bought one of the giant fake Zippo lighters that he had on one of the album sleeves. But they were shit, useless as lighters.
Funnily enough I slept on the same electrostatic carpet in Schenectady that Bob had slept on 4 years previous, and he got shocked too.
See? This life is futile. We never change. Like Sisyphus we will continue to do the exact same mistake again again again.
Life is a garbage can. Full of garbage and in between you find a flower and think: ” How the h.ll did you got in there, but now you are mine, for a time”.
All right we would all like to have eternal life yes?
But what if this eternal life is on a cold boring island full of grey concrete and there is no way you can get off.
Suddenly eternal life become a penalty yes…….. 😅 .
Only England is like that, wake up
Waking Life Ending – YouTube
Reminds me of a theme in my family:”God takes the good guys first and we get one more chance.”
. Gracas a la vida: https://youtu.be/w67-hlaUSIs?list=RDw67-hlaUSIs .
Actually it is amazing how beautiful a landscape the whole planet is, and amazing how wonderful everything to the mouth is designed from our Lord upstairs side.
Yeah but he offended God and got turned into a metaphor. Yes, the wrong kind of eternal life could be a problem. Bur….
as far as I know we already DO have LIFE that reaches beyond this corporeal disposable envelope. …because some of the time I have what I call ‘the view from the Bridge.’
I can’t say how far it extends because I’ve only done so much experimentation, and it depends on the people with whom I am associating. Not the lot I have been living with for the last decade plus. But if you have the right or A right team, you can reach out into other worlds.
Sure. We can close our eyes, and suddenly we are with Alice in Wonderland, Dekemon Digital Monster Dekemon is the best, Tarzan and the Jungle. Travelling in our Dreams.
But……real life should be more exiting and challenging and fulfilling.
But each man, by his own free will.
This thing is not selectively AI, unless you want to postulate the whole thing , the BIG ENCHILADA as AI, which for the moment I am unable to refute.
Yeah but he offended God by telling tales out of school, and so got turned into a metaphor. But….
we have something like extended if not eternal life, that will be a big leap, because I have done a certain amount of experimentation, and I have what I describe as ‘the view from the Bridge,’ sometimes, and I can see down this reality tunnel. And others. And can reach into other worlds/levels. I am certain that this disposable corporeal envelope will follow its programmed path into the recycling bin just like it’s’posed to do.
But if you have the right team around you, you can go places. And provide yourself with conundra that cannot be resolved by earthly experience.
It took me about 5 minutes to crack Dylan’s arrangement of ‘It’s alright \Ma.’. . Capo on the second fret. Bottom E string tuned down to D. Top 3 strings of F shape slid up to G, down to F, now D shape which with the capo is E.
You can figure the rest from that.
Sure. It does initially make some kinda sense. At least at in that specific moment of one’s consciousness. And yet, what then?
The next day. The morning after the evening before. Do such truths still hold the incontrovertible feeling against the rigorous testing of daylight thinking?? Often not. Therein lieth the rub.
Always worth re-approaching basic sanity on such occasions imho
The point is NOT that the external reality tunnel changes, although it CAN, but It changes YOU. Some experiences cannot be gone back on, cannot be reversed.
You can pretend that things that happened did not happen, but SO WHAT?
It’s the difference between viewing a pink elephant (which generally does need to be backtracked on for basic sanity’s sake) and the viewing of events that actually do transpire 30 years later and which nobody can explain.
Preaching to the converted in some sense although not in others
Thanks. Dylan seems to be a modern prophet, appointed. Like so many who were described appointed in the Scriptures. Everything related to God makes me happy, a feeling of wellness. But thanks for the riddle.