118

Indoctrination, Intimidation & Intolerance: What Passes for Education Today

John whitehead

“Every day in communities across the United States, children and adolescents spend the majority of their waking hours in schools that have increasingly come to resemble places of detention more than places of learning.”
Investigative journalist Annette Fuentes

This is what it means to go back-to-school in America today. Instead of being taught the three R’s of education (reading, writing and arithmetic), young people are being drilled in the three I’s of life in the American police state: indoctrination, intimidation and intolerance.

Indeed, while young people today are learning first-hand what it means to be at the epicenter of politically charged culture wars, test scores indicate that students are not learning how to succeed in social studies, math and reading.

Instead of raising up a generation of civic-minded citizens with critical thinking skills, government officials are churning out compliant drones who know little to nothing about their history or their freedoms.

Under the direction of government officials focused on making the schools more authoritarian (sold to parents as a bid to make the schools safer), young people in America are now first in line to be searched, surveilled, spied on, threatened, tied up, locked down, treated like criminals for non-criminal behavior, tasered and in some cases shot.

From the moment a child enters one of the nation’s 98,000 public schools to the moment he or she graduates, they will be exposed to a steady diet of:

  • draconian zero tolerance policies that criminalize childish behavior,
  • overreaching anti-bullying statutes that criminalize speech,
  • school resource officers (police) tasked with disciplining and/or arresting so-called “disorderly” students,
  • standardized testing that emphasizes rote answers over critical thinking,
  • politically correct mindsets that teach young people to censor themselves and those around them,
  • and extensive biometric and surveillance systems that, coupled with the rest, acclimate young people to a world in which they have no freedom of thought, speech or movement.

This is how you groom young people to march in lockstep with a police state.

As Deborah Cadbury writes for The Washington Post, “Authoritarian rulers have long tried to assert control over the classroom as part of their totalitarian governments.”

In Nazi Germany, the schools became indoctrination centers, breeding grounds for intolerance and compliance.

In the American police state, the schools have become increasingly hostile to those who dare to question or challenge the status quo.

America’s young people have become casualties of a post-9/11 mindset that has transformed the country into a locked-down, militarized, crisis-fueled mockery of a representative government.

Roped into the government’s profit-driven campaign to keep the nation “safe” from drugs, disease, and weapons, America’s schools have transformed themselves into quasi-prisons, complete with surveillance cameras, metal detectors, police patrols, zero tolerance policies, lock downs, drug sniffing dogs, strip searches and active shooter drills.

Students are not only punished for minor transgressions such as playing cops and robbers on the playground, bringing LEGOs to school, or having a food fight, but the punishments have become far more severe, shifting from detention and visits to the principal’s office into misdemeanor tickets, juvenile court, handcuffs, tasers and even prison terms.

Students have been suspended under school zero tolerance policies for bringing to school “look alike substances” such as oreganobreath mints, birth control pills and powdered sugar.

Look-alike weapons (toy guns—even Lego-sized ones, hand-drawn pictures of guns, pencils twirled in a “threatening” manner, imaginary bows and arrows, fingers positioned like guns) can also land a student in hot water, in some cases getting them expelled from school or charged with a crime.

Not even good deeds go unpunished.

One 13-year-old was given detention for exposing the school to “liability” by sharing his lunch with a hungry friend. A third grader was suspended for shaving her head in sympathy for a friend who had lost her hair to chemotherapy. And then there was the high school senior who was suspended for saying “bless you” after a fellow classmate sneezed.

Having police in the schools only adds to the danger.

Thanks to a combination of media hype, political pandering and financial incentives, the use of armed police officers (a.k.a. school resource officers) to patrol school hallways has risen dramatically in the years since the Columbine school shooting.

Indeed, the growing presence of police in the nation’s schools is resulting in greater police “involvement in routine discipline matters that principals and parents used to address without involvement from law enforcement officers.”

Funded by the U.S. Department of Justice, these school resource officers have become de facto wardens in elementary, middle and high schools, doling out their own brand of justice to the so-called “criminals” in their midst with the help of tasers, pepper spray, batons and brute force.

In the absence of school-appropriate guidelines, police are more and more “stepping in to deal with minor rulebreaking: sagging pants, disrespectful comments, brief physical skirmishes. What previously might have resulted in a detention or a visit to the principal’s office was replaced with excruciating pain and temporary blindness, often followed by a trip to the courthouse.”

Not even the younger, elementary school-aged kids are being spared these “hardening” tactics.

On any given day when school is in session, kids who “act up” in class are pinned facedown on the floor, locked in dark closets, tied up with straps, bungee cords and duct tape, handcuffed, leg shackled, tasered or otherwise restrained, immobilized or placed in solitary confinement in order to bring them under “control.”

In almost every case, these undeniably harsh methods are used to punish kids—some as young as 4 and 5 years old—for simply failing to follow directions or throwing tantrums.

Very rarely do the kids pose any credible danger to themselves or others.

Unbelievably, these tactics are all legal, at least when employed by school officials or school resource officers in the nation’s public schools.

This is what happens when you introduce police and police tactics into the schools.

Paradoxically, by the time you add in the lockdowns and active shooter drills, instead of making the schools safer, school officials have succeeded in creating an environment in which children are so traumatized that they suffer from post-traumatic stress disorder, nightmares, anxiety, mistrust of adults in authority, as well as feelings of anger, depression, humiliation, despair and delusion.

For example, a middle school in Washington State went on lockdown after a student brought a toy gun to class. A Boston high school went into lockdown for four hours after a bullet was discovered in a classroom. A North Carolina elementary school locked down and called in police after a fifth grader reported seeing an unfamiliar man in the school (it turned out to be a parent).

Police officers at a Florida middle school carried out an active shooter drill in an effort to educate students about how to respond in the event of an actual shooting crisis. Two armed officers, guns loaded and drawn, burst into classrooms, terrorizing the students and placing the school into lockdown mode.

These police state tactics have not made the schools any safer.

The fallout has been what you’d expect, with the nation’s young people treated like hardened criminals: handcuffed, arrested, tasered, tackled and taught the painful lesson that the Constitution (especially the Fourth Amendment) doesn’t mean much in the American police state.

So what’s the answer, not only for the here-and-now—the children growing up in these quasi-prisons—but for the future of this country?

How do you convince a child who has been routinely handcuffed, shackled, tied down, locked up, and immobilized by government officials—all before he reaches the age of adulthood—that he has any rights at all, let alone the right to challenge wrongdoing, resist oppression and defend himself against injustice?

Most of all, how do you persuade a fellow American that the government works for him when, for most of his young life, he has been incarcerated in an institution that teaches young people to be obedient and compliant citizens who don’t talk back, don’t question and don’t challenge authority?

As we’ve seen with other issues, any significant reforms will have to start locally and trickle upwards.

As I make clear in my book Battlefield America: The War on the American People and in its fictional counterpart The Erik Blair Diaries, if we want to raise up a generation of freedom fighters who will actually operate with justice, fairness, accountability and equality towards each other and their government, we must start by running the schools like freedom forums.

Originally published by the Rutherford Institute
Constitutional attorney and author John W. Whitehead is founder and president of The Rutherford Institute. His book Battlefield America: The War on the American People (SelectBooks, 2015) is available online at www.amazon.com. Whitehead can be contacted at [email protected]

SUPPORT OFFGUARDIAN

If you enjoy OffG's content, please help us make our monthly fund-raising goal and keep the site alive.

For other ways to donate, including direct-transfer bank details click HERE.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

118 Comments
newest
oldest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Gayle Wells
Gayle Wells
Aug 28, 2023 10:10 PM

And we’ve place our most treasured things in the hands of these eugenicists and global pirates through their NGO’s and fake philanthropy horror organisations. G.Edward Griffin interview with Norman Dodd proves what they were up to a century ago. They shut the Reese Committee investigation right down. Best interview ever of how real moral and humanly driven people are all about but are silenced. We outnumber these pirates that truly are at the bottom of the pyramid of evolution of the human and divine spirit. They need to be fully brought to justice.

John Manning
John Manning
Aug 19, 2023 1:54 AM

Something new for the white folks. I wonder how many black skinned people think this is a change.

Berlin Beerman
Berlin Beerman
Aug 18, 2023 11:17 PM

What passed for education in the past? When religious institutions like the Catholic Church and others ruled the education systems of countries, was it any better? Now Governments rule them and it’s the same crap all over again.

Parents who have no business being parents in the first place – this is the root issue. concentrate on that and perhaps we may get somewhere. Until then leave it alone because you neither have the knowledge nor the ability to alter it – only the reality of complaint after the fact.

Antonym
Antonym
Aug 16, 2023 12:02 PM

Parents should not pay heftily for their kid’s indoctrination. So a good number of Western “colleges” should be avoided like the plague. Prestigious universities and colleges main function is to mingle with elite youth after hours, which can anyway be done just outside, free of hefty fees – IF desired. Best thing is let your 18+ work to pay their own study, 0n or offline. They probably learn more on their workplace than in the bore benches.

mgeo
mgeo
Aug 17, 2023 7:53 AM
Reply to  Antonym

Learning on the job means dirtying one’s hands, and treating others as equals or superiors. Paying for one’s own sudies means practical management of money. The wealthy imagine that sparing their children these experiences is good, and even fear that they will undermine the bullying streak they are trying to pass on. They want their children to enter the boardroom directly, with con-sultants or AI managing reality for them.

Howard
Howard
Aug 17, 2023 5:22 PM
Reply to  Antonym

That may not entirely be an idea whose time has come, since working minimum wage flipping burgers could possibly fall a bit short of paying even one semester. And what exactly will the prospective student have learned – other than that he or she does not particularly care for the workaday world?

PeterOfPan
PeterOfPan
Aug 16, 2023 9:00 AM

“As Deborah Cadbury writes for The Washington Post“Authoritarian rulers have long tried to assert control over the classroom as part of their totalitarian governments.”

The school system was originally designed by authoritarians in the 1800s and early 1900s. The prussian school system was designed for producing obedient workers and soldiers. This has been a model for the American and other school systems.

Of course we are next leveling the system now. There was a period of softening the system with prohibition on physical punishment by the teachers and other changes, but now the ebb is to different direction.

In words of DISL Automatic:

“The system is not broken,
it was designed this way.
It’s rotten to the core,
we are just trying to strip the filth away .”

-DISL Automatic – Upset the Set Up-

brian of nazareth
brian of nazareth
Aug 16, 2023 6:59 AM

I have been waiting for the introduction of the “straight to jail” initiative for school leavers. Why turn them on to the streets to cause a nuisance when they could be earning profit for private “correction centres”?
The state has a monopoly on violence, so a child who makes a Lego “gun” is punished while the bombs rain down in Iraq, Afghanistan, Ukraine or wherever the state has decided to direct its murderous intent. First lesson today is hypocrisy.

mgeo
mgeo
Aug 16, 2023 7:14 AM

That is the free market, recycling even the reluctant outcastes of society for the greater good of humankind, “development”, security and the holy GDP.

George Mc
George Mc
Aug 16, 2023 6:42 AM

The new Mccarthyism from The Evening Standard:

“Comedy event featuring Graham Linehan cancelled after complaints

Leith Arches said Thursday’s comedy event has been axed because it ‘does not align with our overall values’.

Graham Linehan has been cancelled after complaints were made to the venue.

An Edinburgh venue has axed the Comedy Unleashed event featuring Linehan, a vocal critic of aspects of the trans rights movement, which was due to take place on Thursday.”

Yes indeed, step out of line with the new and insane catechism about an utterly contrived new “community” of oxymoronic phantom beings, and you will find yourself under attack from various mysterious “voices of the people” and your means of livelihood will be gone.

Paul Watson
Paul Watson
Aug 16, 2023 7:17 AM
Reply to  George Mc

Transphobic is the new racist.

PD
PD
Aug 16, 2023 5:19 PM
Reply to  George Mc

This is typical insanity, given that it takes place in Scotland. Given what I’ve read the last few years, it seems that the Scottish Government (can you call it that?) has taken the most childish protest movements from America and turned them in to law!

There are no more “Scottish, or British” adults living in Scotland? Is there no counter movement or counter response to this idiocy?

“‘does not align with our overall values’.

And, what values are those? Even the phrase, or the language usage, has the stupid American nonsense sound.

There is no such thing as “transphobic”. It is babble.

Joe Van Steenbergen
Joe Van Steenbergen
Aug 16, 2023 4:46 AM

We have no one to blame but ourselves; we sat idly by while the left completely conquered the education establishment, and only when covid revealed the horrors of what was really going on in the classroom did we object. But that was way too late; by that time, gender fluidity had completely poisoned the curriculum. Get your kids out of public school if you want them to have any semblance of a life.

Violet
Violet
Aug 16, 2023 8:22 AM

Points 3 and 4 of the Frankfurt School fit with what is happening in schools today.

https://billmuehlenberg.com/2009/05/11/the-frankfurt-school-and-the-war-on-the-west/

Gloria Claggg
Gloria Claggg
Aug 16, 2023 10:57 AM
Reply to  Violet

All eleven points of the Frankfurt School have been achieved!

Erik Nielsen
Erik Nielsen
Aug 16, 2023 12:30 PM

we sat idly by while the left feasted on our children”, precisely!

Wendy
Wendy
Aug 16, 2023 8:16 PM

I taught middle school briefly 1998-2000. It was appalling and I told everyone I met about the horrible things that were happening but no one wants to believe it. The prevailing attitude was, “well, not in MY kid’s school!” Sheeple.

martin
martin
Aug 16, 2023 4:05 AM

Education in my day kept out of social issues. There was a set curriculum and ‘Outcomes’ were exam results. There was no mystery to the questions as all the prevous exams were available.

Joe Smith
Joe Smith
Aug 16, 2023 3:33 AM

OK. I get it. Education is bad. Ignorance is good. Got it. Check. You won me over.

Johnny
Johnny
Aug 16, 2023 2:55 AM

Plus – inculcation, regimentation, castigation and usurpation.
We are $crewed, left, right and centre, by the Left, Right and Centre.

Michael
Michael
Aug 16, 2023 2:09 AM

Education is a weapon, whose effect depends on who holds it in his hands and at whom it is aimed”- Joseph Stalin

wardropper
wardropper
Aug 16, 2023 2:43 AM
Reply to  Michael

If only he had understood what his own words meant…
Like anything else, education can be used as a weapon.
But it is not actually a weapon.
It is what happens when a mind gets sufficiently curious to want to know something.

Thank heaven education is not entirely dependent upon educators.
Human beings have self-consciousness for a reason.

niko
niko
Aug 16, 2023 1:15 AM

Kill the Indian, save the man. This noble motto of Native American boarding schools is just one reminder how education historically has been indoctrination, intimidation and intolerance, including cultural extermination (genocide). While particularly applicable to indigenous peoples, not just in Amerikkka but worldwide (as depicted in the case of Australia with the film Rabbit Proof Fence), its logic of social engineering is essential to industrial skooling generally (cf. Ivan Illich, John Taylor Gatto, Jonathan Kozol, John McKnight).  

Once ruling class interests like the Rockefeller and Carnegie empires invested in the project of universal education to manufacture in factories of generational reproduction the necessary disciplines of dutiful wage slavery to the machinery of production, like mindless obedience to authoritarian taskmasters and treadmills, the thought police were even welcomed, though not without notable neo-Luddite resistance initially, into traditional communities destroyed for the welfare of the people.  

Preference for the Prussian military model of conditioning captive compliance serves as another reminder of modern progress in scientific management and total(itarian) institutions from barracks and assembly lines to classrooms and hospital wards, the prison complex basic to industrial capitalism (cf. Michel Foucalt’s Discipline and Punish).  From settler colonialism’s reservations or concentration camps in Injun country among the first of eugenics’ final solutions, or poor houses for dispossessed peasants turned proletarians with enclosure of the commons and early accumulation of private property, to perfection of the panopticon in the digital (c)age and chattel slavery synthesized, the masses of us live, and die, at various stages of lockdown.

During my lifetime I’ve seen advances in next generation population control from Officer Friendly and the dunces’ corner to maximum security patrols tasering and jailing children, with by far the biggest bully at school the school itself. And it looks like I won’t make my great escape from this trail-of-tears life without some subjection to a new abnormal where precrime begins in preschools on a prison planet.  

I can’t imagine any significant reform as Whitehead calls for short of revolutionary reversal of the control paradigm of human relations inherent to class rule and ownership of land, labor, life that’s long defined us, a death march called civilization contrary to most of human evolution characterized by the Commons of all life, shared in more egalitarian relations. How else do we really respect our inalienable freedom and dignity, and the value of our earthly home?

Maxwell
Maxwell
Aug 16, 2023 1:56 AM
Reply to  niko

Great comment. A tour de force depiction of the current situation.

Bryan
Bryan
Aug 16, 2023 7:51 AM
Reply to  niko

Excellent comment.

If we acknowledge Foucault’s disciplinarian civilisation as penultimate, then surely we must acknowledge the vertex of education as the “civilisation of control”; that which presents us with unlimited ‘free’ choice for the indoctrinated economised individual; as so educated as ultimate? As per Deleuze’s final essay “Postscript on the Societies (civilisation) of Control”.

Then the negative progression is from sovereignty (of kings and emperors); through disciplinarian (Prussian rote indoctrination and detention of dissidence); to the culmination in the Civilisation of the Self as auto-surveillance and personalised self-control presenting as ‘liberty’ and ‘freedom’ of commodified choice, canalised as unidirectional control cybernetics, commanded by the dictatorship of the language (as mots d’ordre “order words.”)

All because the control architecture (economic governmentality of hyperindividuation; the “new individualism” of Thatcher and Reagan) is already firmly in place as the ultimate politically qualified self-regulating mechanism (bios politikos as regula vitae — Agamben)

The ‘Sovereign Individual’ is the control mechanism of voluntary auto-surveillance as totalised self-reference of ‘one’s owned self’ governmentality and self-subjectivation as self-enslavement to the language (auto-grammaticalisation) as per Nietzsche, Foucault, Deleuze and Guattari (whose final essay was “Why everybody wants to be fascist.”)

https://cidadeinseguranca.files.wordpress.com/2012/02/deleuze_control.pdf

Howard
Howard
Aug 16, 2023 10:21 PM
Reply to  niko

It’s unfortunate of course that schools serve so many negative purposes. Perhaps the greatest misfortune is how actual learning is dwarfed by the process – and overlooked by all the critiques.

I’m not talking about curricula, only about the most general educational concept – exposing a child to the existence of books.

Of course books are part of the indoctrination process. But they are far more in that they represent a place where students can begin and carry forward a process of learning on their own.

Perhaps it’s taken for granted that everybody’s family is well acquainted with books, and especially “The Classics.” But that’s not the case – and of course it’s becoming less and less the case nowadays.

The greatest – and perhaps the only – value of schooling is showing students where to look if they wish to acquire knowledge. And second to that is showing students what to look for. In other words, how to read and write.

Cognitive Dissonance
Cognitive Dissonance
Aug 16, 2023 12:47 AM

This is nothing new. HL Mencken wrote this 100 years ago.
“The most erroneous assumption is to the effect that the aim of public education is to fill the young of the species with knowledge and awaken their intelligence, and so make them fit to discharge the duties of citizenship in an enlightened and independent manner. Nothing could be further from the truth. The aim of public education is not to spread enlightenment at all; it is simply to reduce as many individuals as possible to the same safe level, to breed and train a standardized citizenry, to put down dissent and originality. That is its aim in the United States, whatever the pretensions of politicians, pedagogues and other such mountebanks, and that is its aim everywhere else.”

les online
les online
Aug 16, 2023 12:23 AM

After reading articles, such as John Whitehead’s, i can see why many, many people would support the imposition of the WEFs 4IR, especially the imposition of a digital ID-surveillance, tracking & punishment system – such as the Chinese ‘Social Credit’ system…I can see why politicians would feel emboldened to support laws that would greatly increase The State’s intrusions into everyone’s life….
And reading such articles always fills me with dreadful deja vu !
Didnt i read something very similar back there during the 1960s, and 1970s, and 1980s (that gave us Political Correctness, that later morphed into Woke),; and 1990s, and 2000s, and 2010s (Woke arrives fully dressed) ???

e.g:
‘We live in times of unprecedent change…change which often produces stress and social breakdown. Indeed the growth in the crime rate may be attributed….to the breakdown of certain spontaneous agencies of social control which worked in the past. These agencies worked through the family, the Church, through personal and local loyalties, and through a stable life in a stable society.’…Conservative Party 1966 p11,,,

(Some question “If pathogenic ‘viruses’ really existed, surely the human species would have been wiped out long ago ?” …By the same token if the crime rate had increased, and social breakdown worsened, as politicians insist every election, shouldnt society be totally corrupted and chaotic by now ?

(Reminds me of that (Cold War) 1980s poster which asked “Are you tired of waiting for the touted Nuclear War ?” It gave two options to vote on (1) Yes ! Get it over with; (2) No. Can you wait a little bit longer ?)

Bryan
Bryan
Aug 16, 2023 8:10 AM
Reply to  les online

Surely ‘we’ must be cognisant of the fact that the human mind creates not one identity, but two? The most famous modern proponent being Jung; the identity is also the shadow-making factor; Shadow projection is the psychic corollary of identity formation. The archetypal <I> takes the the ‘good’ moral identity and projects the ‘bad’ moral identity as the archetypal dynamic of political friend/enemy antagonisms. Ergo: if we stop with the paranoid-schizoid projection of our own psychic phantasms; the egoic self-consciousness itself collapses. The ego is the friend and the enemy in this bipolar world as a mass psychosis waiting to happen. If not, there will be a new negative to identify with. It is part of our fantasy life not many seem to understand.

Martin Usher
Martin Usher
Aug 15, 2023 10:04 PM

Its all part of the process of “making education more relevant to business”. We had a very nasty scare in the late 60s because of careless education of the post war generation, education that ended up causing large chunks of the generation growing to question things like participation in war, preparation for war, racial and economic divides and all the other good stuff that made us who we are. This was obviously highly undesirable so the idea was sold of making education relevant, the goal being (along with other measures like the War on Drugs) to Put the Fear Of God into a generation, to turn them from socially conscious, questioning people into (initially) pleasure seeking, self-centered drones.

This effort was obviously resoundingly successful. The problem is, though “Now What?”. Mass education may have been a nuisance but the intellectual curiosity unleashed by it created a lot of the modern technological (and thus business) landscape. Conformity drives uniformity so while its good on paper to get a bunch of cowed, conformist robots they’re not a whole lot of use at developing next generation technologies. This might be dismissed as unimportant while we have no effective competition…..but…….

Willem
Willem
Aug 15, 2023 9:16 PM

Pre-covid I thought that most people just acted obediently, out of easiness, opportunism, or just playing nice. Covid, however showed me that it was no play, but that people really need a master who tells them what to do. Seeing how they stayed at home and obsessively followed the rules up to the injection was an eye opener. Putin saved these people from repeatedly injecting themselves with poison till death do us part, as he started his ‘act of aggression,’ after which the rules changed (remember that?). And now we have global climate nonsense. Again.

People like to do what they’re told. Gives them purpose to life. Without it they would not have a clue what to do.

One can say, it could only happy through education. Education made us blind rule followers. -Chomsky argument.

But I no longer believe that argument. People like to have a master who tells them what to do, and that’s it. The only enemy against the master is boredom. Only if people are bored, they might start to think for themselves and for instance realize how f’cked up they are. For which reason we get all these media spectacles.

Bread and circuses.

sok
sok
Aug 15, 2023 10:52 PM
Reply to  Willem

the devil makes work for idle hands

ariel
ariel
Aug 16, 2023 1:33 PM
Reply to  Willem

Yeah, BUT is it ‘nature or nurture?’ The system, and by extension their/our parents program, and in some cases fortunately only unsuccessfully attempted to program ‘people like us.’ aka ‘We are the people our parents warned us about.’
I say this because back in the sixties at religious grammar school, there were only 4 of us in our subversive group, requiring remedial attention from an insufficiently qualified the-rapist in the dinner period.
Moi, Glenn, Ted, and Frank. Cheers guys.

Erik Nielsen
Erik Nielsen
Aug 15, 2023 9:13 PM

The article just throw problems on the table without root cause and history, which is precisely modern western culture and education of today.

Pointing out a problem, and doing it self.

The ideological focus on indoctrination of the public ground school comes from the British Empire, London.
When London went into colonise India (and other colonies) they asked themselves, how do we subdue a well functioning traditional old culture as India in the quickest way?.
The answer was ideological subversion techniques in the heart of society, the children in public ground school.
Same techniques were used by CIA/MI6 in Afghanistan public schools to produce Salafi warriors against Sovjet and it’s friendship with Afghanistan.

Same techniques is used in US for destabilisation, and to subdue a potential US own culture. The root for this is in London Foreign Office.

We have to know this history before we start whining about our many many problems

Veri Tas
Veri Tas
Aug 15, 2023 10:25 PM
Reply to  Erik Nielsen

You have a point there. I remember arriving in Australia in the final year of primary school and having to assemble in the school yard on Monday mornings, singing the praises to the Queen of England. Reminds me of the Hitler Youth system. School uniforms is another pointer of the Anglo fascist nature of schooling – uniformity breeds unquestioning obedience. “You HAVE to!” was one of the first expressions I learned.
Australian micro management at the workplace is another – there was even a docu series about this, with expats living and working in Europe reporting the differences in work culture between European workplaces and Australian ones, screened on mainstream TV about 15-20 years ago.

I think people can only identify this if they have ever lived in different cultures, like yourself presumably.

Erik Nielsen
Erik Nielsen
Aug 16, 2023 12:05 AM
Reply to  Veri Tas

It really helps a lot to see and live other cultures in their language a couple of years.
When you come home you see your country as a foreigner see it :-D. A narrow world.

I dont see school uniforms as especially bad where I have seen them in Africa and Latin. Happy proud children shining all over their faces in their new washed and ironed uniforms. It makes children feel together. They are part of something. Like a classic orchestra in tie and white shirts.

But I know in Anglo culture it can also be full of nasty rituals and unification in a negative way.

Veri Tas
Veri Tas
Aug 16, 2023 10:05 PM
Reply to  Erik Nielsen

I feel school uniforms are always a kind of militarisation in attitude.

Bryan
Bryan
Aug 15, 2023 8:29 PM

Indoctrination, intimidation, intolerance: it was no different undergoing a catholic catechesis back in the late sixties; and I wasn’t even in Ireland where it was really shit in the “Magdalene laundries”; even before the heightened intolerances and intimidations of the ‘Troubles.’ Luckily, there were no priest paedophiles at my school; just some crazed authoritarian dogmaticised indoctrinators. What do people really think ‘education’ is other than detention and disciplinarian psychopaedagogy as inculcation into the dominant form of violent universalised hierarchisation…. or else.

Illich was writing about “deschooling” and “iatrogenic culture” in the sixties ….First do no harm? Before that was the Prussian methodology of rote learning that Wittgenstein practiced with such gusto he severely beat at least one pupil… “That’ll learn him!”

He likened ‘education’ to strict disciplinarianism, mandatory instruction or precise militarised drilling. Paulo Friere further likened psychopaedagogy to the banking method of the authoritarian adult ‘depositing’ facts; shaping the nascent cognition into a calculative accounting mechanism, in preparation for the economic ‘real world.’

If the so-called education is indoctrination, intimidation and intolerance; then so is the culture one is educated as incorporated into; and so is the reductive-mechanistic mind inculcated in the formative years as synaptically shaped into the ‘rational operational’ developmental mode of being. Outside the voluntary detention, discipline and lifelong inculcation there is no such thing. The Joycean “waking up from history” is waking up from bad indoctrination as globalised dominance and isolationist psychopaedagogy.

Psychopaedagogy is literally the infantilised leading the infans into lifelong infantalisation as hyperindividuation — divide et impera — from which most people never fully recover. So why do people continue to see themselves in the way the dominant culture wants people to see themselves as isolated and individuated individuals? Some sort of personalised Stockholm Syndrome?

If ‘we’ want to escape the dominance hierarchies we need to escape individualism as the consummate reductive-mechanistic ideology. We need the paedagogy of the oppressed as andragogy; adult-to-adult and peer-to-peer deschooling and reschooling in more holistic and ecologic ways of being; rejecting the inculcated calculative and possessive individualism of the dominant economic enculturation; which is all toxic and imperialist indoctrination, intimidation and intolerance as ultra-egoification.

Deschooling, degrowth, and “decolonising the indoctrinated economic imaginary” go hand in hand. Buen Viver or individualistic rational barbarism? Consummerist catechesis breeds consummate consumptogenesis until ‘we’ stop it. The individual psyche is the ultimate commodity of bad indoctrination.

ariel
ariel
Aug 16, 2023 2:12 PM
Reply to  Bryan

You have just described what I used to call ‘a German childhood.’ I met my ex-partner’s grandmother. Her first question was, ‘Did you steal the truck?.’ She was the widow of the guy who used to train the SS‘s horses until 1937 when he was formally inducted into the SS. Alleged to have ended up running death camps in Poland. Ran a tractor over both legs to pretend to be an injured farm labourer. Don’t know what he did about the tattoo.
Big story of physical and sexual violence reaching through the generations, a ‘racial?’ psychosis reaching up to my ex- ……personally,
When I was focalising workshops in the 90’s and early 2000s in Central Europe, it became clear that there was quite A BIG MULTI-GENERATIONAL PROBLEM INVOLVING Czechs Germans Danes Austrians etc etc.
I asked the circle of about 20 young people of multi-nationalities, to in turn tell us about their parents, and every single one began, ‘Both (or one of) my parents was a violent alcoholic,’
So we had to extend the definition.
So in 2000 we went to the former Yugoslavia. Sheeesh! Lucky I had already practiced a bit. In Croatia under the Bosnian border (road to Bihac) there was no way to avoid getting involved. The whole place and situation was (still) completely torn up.

ariel
ariel
Aug 16, 2023 2:35 PM
Reply to  ariel

I could only write 2 songs while we were in the former YugoSlavia, ‘Tourists and Consumers,’ and this one, ‘S-S-Sarajevo.’

(2) S-S-SARAJEVO – YouTube This one’s a bit raucous.

Hamish
Hamish
Aug 16, 2023 4:19 PM
Reply to  Bryan

‘Bon viveur’ is more usual than ‘buen viver’, or are you decolonising it?

Bryan
Bryan
Aug 17, 2023 4:57 PM
Reply to  Hamish

It’s from a previous article by Colin Toddhunter which I took to mean “a good life with less” as compatible with Degrowth. A ‘bon viveur’ is therefore the very opposite of what I took the term to mean.

George Mc
George Mc
Aug 15, 2023 8:03 PM

School broke me at the age of 14. That was when I learned a lesson that wasn’t on the curriculum but ubiquitous: that the livelihood you needed to get you through was inevitably going to bore you to death! That was what the teachers taught me by their grudging presence every day. And, given the kind of society we had built, they were correct.

Consequently, the only things that were important, that wouldn’t bore you to death, were the little things you could indulge in from a sheltered corner.

moneycircus
moneycircus
Aug 15, 2023 6:13 PM

Off-G won’t publish me so I get a soft and gentle feeling in my loins when Kit & Co stroke the same topics that came to me in advance.

Not only has the public been dumbed down, but that dumbing down was a preparation for what followed: 9/11, Covid and Climate Change.

So consider depopulation as proceeding not just from Malthus and Oxbridge but those institutions’ role in justifying mercantilism, which was later rebranded as empire and later sanctified through Benjamin Disraeli’s coronation of queen Victoria as empress.

Narrative in service of impetus.

Depop being the bastard offspring of the self-same justification – penetrating itself unasked into the political body.

Follow The Consensus To Your Demise – First of a series on depopulation
https://moneycircus.substack.com/p/crisis-update-follow-the-consensus

Pirates, Privateers And Merchant Adventurers – Second in the series on depopulation
https://moneycircus.substack.com/p/crisis-update-pirates-privateers

Editor excuse my presumption but something more than a choice of East London breakfast diner is at stake.

Clive Williams
Clive Williams
Aug 15, 2023 8:13 PM
Reply to  moneycircus

Actually Americas education system has been forever under pressure from within by this tedious misrepresentation they’re even remotely Englishmen. Lol!

Maxwell
Maxwell
Aug 15, 2023 5:46 PM

Artificial Intelligence= All College Education Circa 2023.

The vast, vast majority of kids at University are Borg minds themselves and only regurgitate the Catechism of Careerism as demanded by the Citadel of Expertise. This is ESPECIALLY the case at the “elite universities.”

Stray too far from the University diktats and dogma put forth by the bought off academics and you will not “move forward” and become a properly credentialed member of the technocratic class.

There isn’t an original idea found anywhere on today’s college campuses.

No machine or algorithm needed to pull this off- it’s all in place. All that is required is blind obedience- that too is fully in place.

Howard
Howard
Aug 15, 2023 5:18 PM

Americans have become obsessed with safety and security; it is therefore highly unlikely adults would lift a finger to protect children from the police state. Most adults’ reaction would be “Thank God they’re finally doing something to keep our kids safe!”

Sandy Hook et al completed the process “911” started. If Sandy Hook did not exist, the police state would have had to invent it.

This mad obsession with security is everywhere, even online. So many websites now – banking sites especially – in addition to the ubiquitous logins, also require special codes which they send to the device of your choice.

I guarantee you the vast majority of Americans would cheer these additional hoops they have to jump through. “Thank God they’re protecting my data!” “My precious precious data! Oh someone please come and save my data!”

Don’t worry: the NSA has heeded your call.

mgeo
mgeo
Aug 16, 2023 7:30 AM
Reply to  Howard

obsessed with safety and security
I doubt it. The oligarchs decide these matters according to how much they can siphon off from public wealth. Any related fear-mongering just sets the stage. And this is not just about “Americans”.

moth
moth
Aug 15, 2023 4:39 PM

Why do we keep referring to Hitler’s socialism, as if that was the worst example of socialism and totalitarianism. Hitler, Stalin and Mao did kindergarten stuff compared to the socialism that’s being imposed on people by the NWO.

Erik Nielsen
Erik Nielsen
Aug 15, 2023 9:21 PM
Reply to  moth

To keep the eye away from City of London where all this come from.

Miranda
Miranda
Aug 15, 2023 4:30 PM

I’ve heard that school attendance rates are now at their lowest ever, with many missing children, and I’m glad, in the hope that children and parents have cottoned on to what’s going on. I wish I’d home-schooled my children, but it would have been difficult, on my own with no funds, needing to work. My mother taught me to read and write, before I went to school, aged four. Very little of what I learnt at school has been useful in life. I had dared to hope that things might have been different, after COVID, with some new and better systems developing, but there only seems to be the grotesque new syllabus of sex and CRT education, and the discovery that school data is collected and used. If I had a child now I would not send them to school, and I would not get them vaccinated in their first year. I might not even register their birth, and then they wouldn’t receive a National Insurance number.

underground poet
underground poet
Aug 15, 2023 6:13 PM
Reply to  Miranda

Which is why i’m beginning to wonder who will be the first insurance company to default, looks like fire to me.

Too many ways to start one for free, and the cost to replace the fire damages has a margin which not only cant be competed with on a different insurance basis, like flood, it also cant be sustained by asking everyone else today, to front todays and tomorrows cost to fire insure.

The customers and company’s will both bow out in the name of metal roofing & siding.

arielazalexander
arielazalexander
Aug 15, 2023 9:54 PM

Sod fire and flood, I don’t think they’re going to attempt to cope with direct murderous attacks from their own ‘government’ with technology that still isn’t officially supposed to exist.

underground poet
underground poet
Aug 15, 2023 10:29 PM

Public side or private side, take your gvt choice.
Coping for the moment, or existing in the long run, take your pick.
Believers achievers, or Achievers believers, take your pick.
It’s all as plain as the nose on your face.

DOA
DOA
Aug 15, 2023 4:22 PM

Hated school.

Every day in communities across the United States, children and adolescents spend the majority of their waking hours in schools that have increasingly come to resemble places of detention more than places of learning.”
Investigative journalist Annette Fuentes

This was the why.

Erik Nielsen
Erik Nielsen
Aug 15, 2023 9:27 PM
Reply to  DOA

Its the same today in Europe. The children I ask: “Do you like to go to school”?
The two answers I get is: “No we hate it”, “No”. This is children telling their honest feelings. This is a very very bad sign.

Nick Baam
Nick Baam
Aug 15, 2023 3:20 PM

‘Instead of raising up a generation of civic-minded citizens with critical thinking skills, government officials are churning out compliant drones who know little to nothing about their history or their freedoms.’

Oh, that’s been going on for quite a while, w words any decent principal would forbid being spoken in his school.

“I pledge allegiance to the flag….”

arielazalexander
arielazalexander
Aug 15, 2023 10:19 PM
Reply to  Nick Baam

Well, I got a slightly different form of indoctrination, but if didn’t stick. But I wrote this anyway. I only lived in the US for about 3 years, but it was enough, It always felt as if the whole thing was about to tip over.

OATH TO THE FLAG – YouTube

Rhys Jaggar
Rhys Jaggar
Aug 15, 2023 2:00 PM

The most obvious response to that litany of nonsense is ‘home schooling’. Of course, parents who do that need to network with similar minded parents, building up a network of complementary relevant life skills and subject knowledge so that the box tickers can be satisfied that the mundane rote learning material has been absorbed.

The description is above is a total climate of fear, with schools petrified of being sued by parents, being punished by politicians and being demonised by the police.

It could be changed pretty easily by competent School Principals, but most likely such folks would be sidelined by box-ticking apparatchiks if they tried to sort things out.

One of these decades American society will realise that they have hit rock bottom and maybe then they will get off their backsides to effect change.

Right now, the descent into tyranny is well underway and for outsiders, the only question is what kind of a revolution will eventually sweep through the USA. It might be violent, it might be a civil war, it might be a complete rejection of both Republicans and Democrats, mass cancellation of MSM subscriptions etc etc.

Sadly for most Americans, their Constitution is no longer worth the piece of parchment it was most likely written down on.

wardropper
wardropper
Aug 15, 2023 2:27 PM
Reply to  Rhys Jaggar

I fear the shame and humiliation of realizing that they have hit rock bottom will make them reluctant to admit it publicly.

So nothing will change.

TRT
TRT
Aug 15, 2023 3:49 PM
Reply to  Rhys Jaggar

I hope the outsiders watching the US descend into tyranny also realize that their own countries are descending into tyranny.

Erik Nielsen
Erik Nielsen
Aug 15, 2023 9:32 PM
Reply to  TRT

If that makes you happy.
But if you Americans, who have all rights to own a riffle and more freedom and money flow than anyone else, cant protect your own country……

Do you want Bangladesh come and save you?

TRT
TRT
Aug 15, 2023 10:49 PM
Reply to  Erik Nielsen

If what makes me happy? I’m Canadian, and decidedly unhappy about what is happening in Canada.

Where do you live?

Erik Nielsen
Erik Nielsen
Aug 15, 2023 11:52 PM
Reply to  TRT

Europe. No gun rights, No knife rights in public. Gatherings in public only after application in advised areas. 50-70% taxation. Job applications only accepted on electronic faceless schedules signed by Digital ID. Cars banned in green areas. Traffic fines issued automatically by surveillance cameras. m.m.

Hemlockfen
Hemlockfen
Aug 16, 2023 6:29 PM
Reply to  Erik Nielsen

Met a woman through a dating app that loved Austria. Especially the “free” stuff like health care and public transportation. And the open borders (which are not as open as she implied). She neglected to point out that 30% of population was unemployed young people who were only interested in traveling around Europe and the high tax rate of 50%. She owned a touring company that catered to women and all her guides were, of course, women. I was surprised she was looking for a man. I told her she should move there if it is so great. She lives in Bay Harbor, MI. Very wealthy community. There was no second date.

Erik Nielsen
Erik Nielsen
Aug 17, 2023 3:15 PM
Reply to  Hemlockfen

Yeah, the old story. The grass is greener on the other side of the fence.
When people get bored in their daily struggle they dream..
But they all get disappointed. After two years they begin to realize they are not getting anywhere.
Even if they have education they have to take it all over again, because the EU systems consider their systems to be superior.

There is no better place anywhere, same boss, same problems.
It has to e based on love and sincere interest for the other part to have chance..

Victor G.
Victor G.
Aug 15, 2023 4:20 PM
Reply to  Rhys Jaggar

Never has an empire/country/people so richly deserved their immanent collapse.
That day is nigh, the billions are preparing. the celebrations.

underground poet
underground poet
Aug 15, 2023 6:18 PM
Reply to  Victor G.

And after all the celebrations what? More partying in the streets, I can hardly wait

Clive Williams
Clive Williams
Aug 16, 2023 3:16 AM

I’ll donate an Apple if you see an American on the street after supper.

underground poet
underground poet
Aug 16, 2023 11:22 AM
Reply to  Clive Williams

After dinner walk a mile,

After supper rest a while.

Paul Vonharnish
Paul Vonharnish
Aug 16, 2023 1:11 AM
Reply to  Rhys Jaggar

From “The New Colossus”

“Keep, ancient lands, your storied pomp!” cries she

With silent lips. “Give me your tired, your poor,

Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free,

The wretched refuse of your teeming shore.

Send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to me,

I lift my lamp beside the golden door!”

Ya great. Send me your poor homeless wretched trash from every “teeming” shore… What could possibly go wrong?

Thomas Frey
Thomas Frey
Aug 15, 2023 1:56 PM

If your children are still in public schools then they are being psychologically abused and the parents are facilitating that abuse.

Like the poster said below, home schooling is the solution. Cost or sacrifice is a irrelevant.

wardropper
wardropper
Aug 15, 2023 2:25 PM
Reply to  Thomas Frey

Except that bad home schooling has just as catastrophic an effect on children as bad standard schooling…

Being a wise, or even a competent teacher is a long, long way from being within the grasp of just anybody, and implying that people automatically have the qualities required constitutes great disrespect for those accredited teachers who actually know what they’re doing, and who care enough to fight for the freedom to do their work without political interference.

Teaching has always been regarded as a vocation.
Until now, of course.
Today, it’s become a mixture of baby-sitting and mandatory brainwashing.
If that doesn’t change, Hell on Earth awaits us.

I just wish I even knew how to start changing things.
There really don’t seem to be enough angry parents around yet.
Most are too busy getting ready to roll out the red carpet for Big Bro’s Coronation Day…

zenpriest
zenpriest
Aug 15, 2023 8:35 PM
Reply to  wardropper

Honestly I’m sure that being at school reduced my intelligence, my abilities and my prospects. It ruined my outlook on the world. Even if you took your kids out but didn’t school them – I think they call it ‘no schooling’, they would be better off.

wardropper
wardropper
Aug 16, 2023 2:37 AM
Reply to  zenpriest

My experience was different:

School certainly had its drawbacks and its nightmares, but after school I simply went home and then I had plenty of time to do my own thing and learn about the things that aroused my own personal curiosity.

At the time, I would have liked to skip school and concentrate on several hobbies that I had, but with hindsight, I can see that school taught me more than a schoolmaster’s seemingly random discipline.
It taught me about the links between somebody else’s idea of discipline and the evolution of one’s own self-discipline.

That of course doesn’t mean copying other people – after all, some of those disciplinarians were obnoxious people – but I’d say it’s generally better to earn the privilege of being able to do your own thing in later life, rather than just demand it.

Invisible Man
Invisible Man
Aug 17, 2023 5:52 PM
Reply to  wardropper

Your experience is not remotely the norm. I’m glad it worked out for you, but that doesn’t legitimize the system as a whole, which is today and has long been a colossal failure if the inculcation of real knowledge and wisdom is the purpose. As for your “plenty of time to do my own thing,” how old are you may I ask? Because that has not been the norm either for many, many decades. On the contrary, young people’s after school time is usually eaten up with homework, which is usually mindless busywork.

Ort
Ort
Aug 17, 2023 7:21 PM
Reply to  Invisible Man

It’s not just homework. I have a relative, M., who’s been a successful award-winning career “educator”: high school teacher, administrator, and principal. Since he’s a workaholic type, when he voluntarily stepped down from the principalship he returned to the classroom as an ‘umble teacher again rather than face the “void” (to him) of retirement.

Over the years, M. has facetiously deplored the problem or danger of permitting children and teenagers to have “large blocks of unstructured (or “unsupervised”) free time”. M. prizes “achievement”, and accordingly made sure that his two children were required to participate in institutional or organized extracurricular activities to minimize their ability to “lay around” and “do nothing”, and indoctrinate them into the absolute value of being “productive”.

M. is prosperous, if not affluent, so maybe the mania for regulating after-school and other nominal “free time” activity is more easily gratified in a “privileged” suburban setting. I mention this just to say that I realize that for less fortunate families, the problem may be that there is a lack of presumptively wholesome “free time” options for kids.

But my sense is that those “large blocks of unstructured (or “unsupervised”) free time” have generally fallen into disfavor as a slippery slope into vicious diversions, breeding slackers and even subversives, and generally permitting or encouraging deplorable and “delinquent” behavior.

So the status quo seems to be that, to the extent possible, adults must ensure that children are kept busy with organized, supervised “recreational” activities, with perhaps some leeway for social-media “fun”, until they are tired out and ready for bed. 🤔

Invisible Man
Invisible Man
Aug 17, 2023 6:03 PM
Reply to  zenpriest

Same here, zenpriest. I’m also unpersuaded by wardropper’s contention that

Being a wise, or even a competent teacher is a long, long way from being within the grasp of just anybody, and implying that people automatically have the qualities required constitutes great disrespect for those accredited teachers who actually know what they’re doing, and who care enough to fight for the freedom to do their work without political interference.

The problem with this claim is that such “wise teachers” constitute only a minuscule minority of the profession. I can only think of a couple I had who could be described thus. The vast majority of teachers are not like that at all, and are too broken and brainwashed themselves by the very same insidious system to be of any help to teens and pre-teens trying to survive with their minds and souls intact. Even if these teachers are not actively malicious and sadistic bullies — which many of them are — they are still too unhealthy and lacking in self-awareness to be of service. And that’s not to even mention the cancerous control nexus of politicians, bureaucrats, and administrators working to stifle any real originality or imagination in how students are taught.

wardropper
wardropper
Aug 15, 2023 1:44 PM

We just need a backlash.
It will come.

Thomas Frey
Thomas Frey
Aug 15, 2023 1:57 PM
Reply to  wardropper

History has proven that many innocent people will perish before enough wake up

wardropper
wardropper
Aug 15, 2023 2:08 PM
Reply to  Thomas Frey

Quite right.
I wish I could do something about that.

Hemlockfen
Hemlockfen
Aug 15, 2023 11:18 AM

Wow!

I could have sworn you were quoting the mayor of Chicago (who was once a social studies teacher in the Chicago public schools) that was defending the behavior of teen aged mobs that were beating and robbing innocent people in Chicago’s downtown shopping district. The mayor must have read your book and took it to heart.

These kids have no parents (figuratively). They are all victims of their own mentality which revolves around hate and racism. Combine the lack of discipline at home with the radical curricula common in Blue State schools and all you get is a class of dangerous, disrespectful thugs that only respond to brutality.

Just a story in the “news” about an 8 year old boy, already a chronic trouble maker, that thought he had killed that “bitch” (teacher) with a gun he pilfered into school. His mother’s unsecured gun. The 8 year old knew the security system and figured out how to bypass it. Mom was charged for not securing her gun. With the current justice system, facilitated with Soros money, she will most like get off with a slap on the hand.

We have all seen the results everywhere with the smash and grab mobs. The riots. The burning of cities. Etc. Etc. Few if any are arrested, prosecuted or jailed.

Did it start in the schools or were the schools forced to resort to those tactics because of the lack of parenting by parents who lack parenting skills?

It is all about perspective.

lynch
lynch
Aug 15, 2023 12:52 PM
Reply to  Hemlockfen

This person is supposedly a Christian.

Your that type I bang on about.

Its new moon so I suppose that is maybe one of the reasons.

facilitated with Soros money, she will most like get off with a slap on the hand.

We have all seen the results everywhere with the smash and grab mobs. The riots. The burning of cities. Etc. Etc. Few if any are arrested, prosecuted or jailed.

It is all about perspective ??? which clearly you dont have, the title is Indoctrination, Intimidation & Intolerance: What Passes for Education alt media today.

Ultra naive Conservative MIC funded not alternative media has really got you. That is the fear porn lies they puke.

Thomas Frey
Thomas Frey
Aug 15, 2023 1:58 PM
Reply to  lynch

So are you saying that public schools are a good thing and harmless?

Hemlockfen
Hemlockfen
Aug 15, 2023 3:39 PM
Reply to  Thomas Frey

You tell me. Who is at fault? Children learning to act like adult thugs. What do you do? I grew up in the nonsensical environment. Every day was a challenge and we only had 20% minorities. I don’t know the numbers off hand. But they are big. Fatherless families. Crime ridden neighborhoods. Evacuated businesses. Etc. Even the police, the ones that have not quit, avoid these neighborhoods. Crime is off the charts everywhere. I was in outdoor education for 20 years and spent many a day doing nature programs in the low income neighborhood schools and the juvenile detention centers. I was scared for my life each time I went. It was crazy 40 years ago. Doing that today would be insane. Where do you start? Government give away programs have only made things worse. All that money we contributed, willingly, was nothing but a waste. And now, after contributing all of that tax money to help, average middle class whites are being vilified for being “privileged”. You can lead a horse to water but you cannot make it drink. The socioeconomically disadvantaged populations have had a pathway to follow but refused to do so. Government has bent over backwards to identify and meet their needs. What do you do? Meanwhile, 20 million illegals have scattered throughout our country in recent years and, more than likely, they will succeed. They will bust their asses and assimilate into the population. And they will be happy. Why aren’t the existing populations succeeding? That’s a rhetorical question. I have been there and have seen it first hand. Experience is everything. Creating a system that promotes fatherless families is a primary contributor to the problem. No policing is another major contributor. There is no accountability at any level. The HBO show, The Chi, is fiction.

Paul Vonharnish
Paul Vonharnish
Aug 16, 2023 1:02 AM
Reply to  Hemlockfen

“Creating a system that promotes fatherless families is a primary contributor to the problem.”

Yup. Exactly as designed…

PD
PD
Aug 17, 2023 4:28 PM
Reply to  Hemlockfen

Living in one the large urban area of USA, I have seen it since the 70s.
It was very bad then, worse in the 80s continuing on to the present psychosis. What you say is not just true, but obvious to anyone who cares to look.
Your comments, based on personal experiences, are exactly right and much appreciated.

“… will bust their asses and assimilate into the population. And they will be happy. Why aren’t the existing populations succeeding? ”

Yes. They work hard and bring traditional values”, religious, hard working, marriage, families etc.

Meanwhile the other group of perennial “victims”, need constant attention and financial support from the tax payers. For 50 years, and all it gets worse.

Clive Williams
Clive Williams
Aug 16, 2023 10:37 AM
Reply to  Thomas Frey

US still experiences the odd global gun fire climate warming…rare…but it has been known….

wardropper
wardropper
Aug 15, 2023 2:07 PM
Reply to  lynch

You’re that type I bang on about.
No charge.

Hemlockfen
Hemlockfen
Aug 15, 2023 3:43 PM
Reply to  wardropper

Bang away. You have no clue. I started working when I was 9 years old and never quit. Busted my ass for everything I have. That “type”. No charge on my part either. Maybe you you should pay me to get some insight on reality. Clearly you are disconnected.

underground poet
underground poet
Aug 15, 2023 6:22 PM
Reply to  Hemlockfen

Just as long as heads don’t roll in the morning, we should be alright to get paid.

wardropper
wardropper
Aug 15, 2023 6:30 PM
Reply to  Hemlockfen

I was pointing to the “you’re”, and nothing else. I know nothing about your life or your hardships. We all have those.

But don’t worry about it.
And I’m connected just fine – thanks for asking.

Hemlockfen
Hemlockfen
Aug 17, 2023 9:43 PM
Reply to  wardropper

OK. Sorry. A grammatical thing. Not a grammatical scholar. My wife was and was my go to. She died in 17. When she was alive she would not have allowed most of what I write to be published with this group. My bad.

Paul Vonharnish
Paul Vonharnish
Aug 15, 2023 1:59 PM
Reply to  Hemlockfen

Whoa!!! Don’t push that “lack of parenting” button. Parents of normalized children will take offence, and send riot police after you…

Hemlockfen
Hemlockfen
Aug 17, 2023 9:44 PM

I am laughing. Not sure if I should be, but I am.

Paul Vonharnish
Paul Vonharnish
Aug 18, 2023 1:09 AM
Reply to  Hemlockfen

Heh… At least someone gets the humor… I’m glad you’re not normal…

rossgopicotrain
rossgopicotrain
Aug 15, 2023 4:38 PM
Reply to  Hemlockfen

Let’s attempt to be a tad more sophisticated and nuanced in our pondering on said issue (i.e., the current state of the public education system in America); as both realities described above (yours & the author’s) can be true even if prima facie they seem to be paradoxical. Yes; Mr. Whitehead’s description of the state of public education system in America appears to be apt vis-a-vis the general trajectory that said sphere has taken over the past 30 years or so; and, yes, the reality you describe above is also true: a significant number of schools in the U.S.A. have students who behave in the exact way you describe: belligerent; violent; and criminal. However, these two positions are really not paradoxical nor discontiguous: they are symptoms/reflections of a much larger system of power and control; one that incorporates a circular, causal feedback loop (i.e., cybernetics) in an attempt to ensure that no man, woman or child escapes the all-seeing eye of the panopticon (i.e., Mr. Whitehead’s position); nor its requisite socio-political polarities * (your position).

* For the cybernetics feed-back loop to maintain itself, a Hegelian dialectics needs to be employed, viz. ‘problems-reactions-solutions’ are required for the machine to move on; and, moreover, more times than not those said ‘problems and solutions’ have been created by the Kakistocracy; with the concomitant ‘reactions’ provided by the plebs and proles.

That is all! RGB-Y3 out!!

Hemlockfen
Hemlockfen
Aug 15, 2023 6:49 PM

It’s all about reparations. Getting a payout for their ancestor’s “free labor”. Anti white woke curricula. It’s everywhere. It’s an attitude being promoted by Democrats for political gain. Everyone has a chip on his or her shoulder because of it.

Do the calculations of what you think they may be owed. Then calculate what they have already been given and figure out the difference.

My sense is that it would be break even at best.

Given that there were relatively few slaves as compared to the populations getting the “assistance” now, I would tend to think that the slave descendants might owe money. Incredulous, isn’t it?

PD
PD
Aug 17, 2023 4:50 PM
Reply to  Hemlockfen

Yes, sadly the Democrats are long past the party of union labor (like my father ‘s generation). They have extended the “victim” culture for political expediency.
Celebrating “victims” and destoying Western Civilzation is a social trend which can produce a certain percentage of votes in various places.
The political parties need to stay in power and control, and have consultants analyzing these trends.
Their destructive effect on society is unimportant to the members of Congress!

Regarding reparations, there is no need to calculate anything. This is simply one group who feels a political momentum on it’s side, pressuring another group, who are simply cowards. It is an opportunistic power play.

Hemlockfen
Hemlockfen
Aug 17, 2023 9:48 PM
Reply to  PD

I don’t entirely agree but I agree enough. It’s a blame game. I could get really offensive but I won’t. Basic message I push: Work hard and you will be rewarded.

Erik Nielsen
Erik Nielsen
Aug 15, 2023 9:43 PM
Reply to  Ludger

Fok KS. Only 3 days ago.
What he really mean is that every penny will be transparent. Thats what he mean.
Open books, open wallets. I had to give you a thumb for this disturbing my evening link.

Stewart
Stewart
Aug 15, 2023 8:33 AM

The answer is simple.

Home schooling.

Violet
Violet
Aug 15, 2023 1:41 PM
Reply to  Stewart

Easier said than done when both/single parents have to work just to make ends meet.

Paul Vonharnish
Paul Vonharnish
Aug 15, 2023 2:00 PM
Reply to  Stewart

Or just shoot the little fuckers…

Victor G.
Victor G.
Aug 15, 2023 4:23 PM

Are you looking for a job? Is it something you’d be willing to do?

Erik Nielsen
Erik Nielsen
Aug 15, 2023 9:52 PM
Reply to  Victor G.

I heard some economists had made a calculation that a child cost the adults $300000 in average for their first 20 years.

Imagine if you have 3 1/2 children, this is about $1 million they cost you on the excel sheet over 20 years.
Its that money we are talking about man :-D.

Hemlockfen
Hemlockfen
Aug 16, 2023 6:10 PM
Reply to  Erik Nielsen

Plus, they sap your energy.

mastershock
mastershock
Aug 15, 2023 8:45 PM

My type of parent.  😂 

Hemlockfen
Hemlockfen
Aug 19, 2023 8:34 PM

Before they shoot you! Only one beer in…..

wardropper
wardropper
Aug 15, 2023 2:03 PM
Reply to  Stewart

Like self -sufficient gardening, that sounds good – at first sight…

But practically all parents are divorced/separated these days, and a single parent with a necessary, but low-paid job isn’t going to find home schooling all that attractive a proposition.
One does, after all, tend to be knackered after a long day’s low-paid work.
Sleeping pills and anti-depressants will probably have more appeal.

Our huge problem at the moment is that there is no understanding of, or respect for, education at all.
For the teachers, it’s become just a job like any other, and for the students, it’s become pernicious poison.
How to break the vicious circle is the burning issue of the day.

It would be nice if the answer was simple…

MehNotGreat
MehNotGreat
Aug 15, 2023 4:14 PM
Reply to  wardropper

Frankly, nothing at all would be preferable to what passes for education these days, but unfortunately the lack of a paper saying you graduated from RandoGarbage School makes one unemployable these days.

Ah, the liberty of modernity!

mgeo
mgeo
Aug 16, 2023 7:46 AM
Reply to  wardropper

There are also the administrative tasks and superfluous reports (to clueless adminitrators) that teachers bear.

Erik Nielsen
Erik Nielsen
Aug 16, 2023 10:57 AM
Reply to  wardropper

“How to break the vicious circle” is the most burning complicated global problem we have of today, we cannot understand it. Science has to do their utmost with much more research and funding.
Many many more experiments with home schooling, Internet schooling, forest off grid schooling before we can find out how we can must be doing it.

Scientists and experts must stand shoulder by shoulder globally trying to find out how we do public ground school for our children better than before, because we have still not understood it.
Obsolete read, write and arithmetics, is the last thing we will ever return to.
“We are the world…..a.s.o.”

PD
PD
Aug 17, 2023 5:03 PM
Reply to  wardropper

>>all parents are divorced/separated these days

Yes, and why is that?

Education starts with your mother.
The fact is this. If you have not been taught how to read and write BEFORE you get to kindergarten or 1st grade (in USA, this is 5 – 6 years old), your “PARENT” is an irresponsible, lazy fool. And there the blame lies. This child is at a major disadvantage, perhaps for life. Not the school’s fault.

STJOHNOFGRAFTON
STJOHNOFGRAFTON
Aug 15, 2023 3:04 PM
Reply to  Stewart

Simple but true. A great alternative to education in a Shawshank brain washing factory.

Albert Anderson
Albert Anderson
Aug 15, 2023 3:26 PM
Reply to  Stewart

Isn’t that a little like giving up, like letting them win. What about changing the fucking system? Home schooling sounds simple, but that’s not necessarily an option for a lot of people.

underground poet
underground poet
Aug 15, 2023 6:24 PM

@What about changing the fucking system?

Just make sure the cure isn’t worse than the poison.